55 replies to this topic

[BK40]

MY cousin forward this to me the other day on a farm in Hllsdale. I have relatives who saw multiple sightings in this county in the last ten years. How big do you think this cat is?

Attached Thumbnails

• 

[squirrel slayer]

thats an awesome pic. my guess is 70-100 lbs. kinda looks like the camera angle is making it look bigger than it should be but either way still a nice pic.

[ghug92]

Nice picture, if only DEC acknowledged that they were in fact in Ny. The longer they wait the worse...

[bkln]

Holy smokes, that's a big kitty, and that's exactly why you should always carry a piece with you, bow season or not...just saying...I'm not saying that I do....allegedly... :-)

[bkln]

I just realized I also hunt in this area...man...you just scared the crap out of me...

Edited by bkln, 06 October 2012 - 07:51 PM.

[sbuff]

Did they notify DEC at all.

[WNY Bowhunter]

That photo could be from anywhere...

[waterweasle]

and theres been tons of "sightings" that after someinvestigation turned out to be anything from large house cat to someones dog

[bkln]

Not for nothing BK, how can you tell this was really taken in Columbia county?

[Guns&ReligionCop]

Holy smokes, that's a big kitty, and that's exactly why you should always carry a piece with you, bow season or not...just saying...I'm not saying that I do....allegedly... :-)

Always have a ratchet with me, You're crazy walking the woods without one. I was coming out the other night and I had a gray fox coming running up within 10 feet of me. He stopped and looked figured something was wrong and split. He was 1 foot away from a Speer .38 JHP +P.

I love how states keep denying that these exist with the overwhelming amoun of proof that they do!

[waterweasle]

Always have a ratchet with me, You're crazy walking the woods without one. I was coming out the other night and I had a gray fox coming running up within 10 feet of me. He stopped and looked figured something was wrong and split. He was 1 foot away from a Speer .38 JHP +P.

I love how states keep denying that these exist with the overwhelming amoun of proof that they do!

what overwhelming amount of proof?

[Guns&ReligionCop]

Reports from PA-CT of sightings, trail camera photos, dna evidence and oh yea one got killed by a car last year in CT

http://www.nytimes.c...ticut.html?_r=0

PS:There is a reason they call Penn State the Nittany Lions!

[waterweasle]

yeah one cat that was spotted, and left DNA samples in its wake......................that traveled from what was it, N Dakota??? doesent make a sustainable population,

[Guns&ReligionCop]

We aren't talking about big foot here, we are talking about something that was indiginous to the region. North Dakota is a pretty long walk. Find that hard to believe. I know a farmer in Brooklyn PA that called DEC because he was having a problem with one and wanted to kill it legally. They said that MT Lions don't exist in PA even though he had multiply pictures and eveyone in his family had seen it. So he asked them if doesn't exist theres nothing stopping me from killing it because it doesn't exist. The DEC gave him a 24 hr number to call and they would come and get if he got it. Even if this one did walk from ND you can't believe others had or made the closer trek down from Canada? All of these sightings are hoax's?

[NYBuckHunter27]

6/01/2012?

[eagle rider]

I dunno,.... It took NYS a long time to fess up to the wild boar issue after sightings were reported from Erie Cty all the way east to Broome and Cortland. Adirondack area folks have been talking about big kitty's for the last decade. I have seen them in the flesh (or fur as it would be) in the South Carolina Low Country. They are no nonsense animal. That said,... It wouldn't surprise me in the least if the good folks at the DEC were trying to keep a lid on this.

[paula]

6/01/2012?

that is june 1 2012

[waterweasle]

<sup>first result I found.......... http://www.reuters.c...E76Q5ZE20110727


theres been tons of "sightings" from all over the place, NY and beyond that proved to be anything but a mountain lion, again, large house cats to golden retrievers have been falsly ID'd as lions, and with all the game cameras that are out there, you would think that a few more pictures would show up</sup>

[SteveB]

Reports from PA-CT of sightings, trail camera photos, dna evidence and oh yea one got killed by a car last year in CT

http://www.nytimes.c...ticut.html?_r=0

PS:There is a reason they call Penn State the Nittany Lions!

The CT cat was proven not to be from the NE.
Would love to see and verified dna, scat, or any physical evidence.
Funny thing ion the sightings - more allegedly get sited here then in the states out west where they have seasons and bodies.

[covert]

ND is a long walk, but it's not like he had anything better to do. Didn't have to be to work Monday morning.