Recommended Posts

The problem with your scenario is that there isn’t a perfect gun or cartridge.

 

A lightweight revolver in 41mag or 44mag with a quality hollow point bullet would be ideal for ending a wounded bears day. However the scenario could change quickly and the gun you choose could very easily become a personal defense weapon if said wounded bear decides he’s still got some fight in him. Here is where a semi would be ideal. When stressed accuracy falls and the more holes you can get into a critter the better of you’ll be. This is where a light revolver sucks and a semi shines.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I’m leaning towards a .357 mag right now. If I can find a place to rent a .44 mag and 10mm I might consider those options as well.

Unfortunately I don’t know of any ranges that rent hand guns in those calibers.

If I end up with a buy I’ll post pictures.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

22  but wait til he's really close and shoot between the eyes

 


A man convinced against his will is of the same opinion still

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, nybuckboy said:

22  but wait til he's really close and shoot between the eyes

 

Put a lot of thought into that idea did ya ?! Maybe a straw and spitballs too. ? 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Buddy of mine swears by his G20 (10mm) and he's got some really fat ninja bears on his hunting land.
This plus Underwood ammo, 220 grain hardcast hit like a ton of bricks, out of my G20 with as 6 inch barrel is devastating.

Sent from my SM-G900T3 using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I own both 357mag and 44mag i feel either well do the job of an easy and quick kill of a wounded animal.Also well fend off any attack of animal in these NY woods......I also like revolvers more then semi auto's again I own both....Good luck....Let us know which you decide on...
Ruger just came out with a 10mm super redhawk

Sent from my SM-G900T3 using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
38 minutes ago, TACC said:

Ruger just came out with a 10mm super redhawk

Sent from my SM-G900T3 using Tapatalk
 

Looks neat.  Not sure I’m a moon clip fan 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ruger just came out with a 10mm super redhawk

Sent from my SM-G900T3 using Tapatalk


I have been a 10mm fan for a log time and have 4 of them however I see no use in a 10mm revolver. As hard as it tries a 10mm isn’t even close to a 41mag.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22 hours ago, Padre86 said:

 Even so, I think pistols can’t have a barrel length any longer than 16”; I’ve no intent of carrying a pistol anywhere close to that size. 

To clarify, long guns can't be 16 or under or it is a SBR.  A pistol can be over. I know it certainly wouldn't fit your bill in those lengths. 

I've shot the 357,41 and 44 Mags. I've used the 357 to dispatch deer. I would opt for the 41 given your previous comments. I would want it heavier than the 357  and you seem concerned about the 44 recoil (it is "stout" with a heavy hunting load). The 41 would be a perfect compromise. 


"Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch. Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote." -- Benjamin Franklin

"The trouble with Socialism is, sooner or later you run out of other people's money." - Margaret Thatcher

"When you subsidize poverty and failure, you get more of both.." - James Dale Davidson, National Taxpayers Union

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

10mm and .357 are almost exactly the same energy wise except the 10mm is .40 caliber vs .38. I would go with something big enough to take down a bear but still able to get multiple rounds out of the gun accurately because you won't always hit on the 1st shot when in a life or death situation. I would recommend either the 10mm or .357. I like pistols so I personally would opt for the 10mm.

Edited by chas0218

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10mm and .357 are almost exactly the same energy wise except the 10mm is .40 caliber vs .38. I would go with something big enough to take down a bear but still able to get multiple rounds out of the gun accurately because you won't always hit on the 1st shot when in a life or death situation. I would recommend either the 10mm or .357. I like pistols so I personally would opt for the 10mm.

 

Yes, on average .357 seems to throw slightly smaller projectiles but at a faster velocity and higher energy; I think the hunting rounds can peak at 750 to 800 lb ft.

 

10mm is capable of throwing heavier grain bullets, though the hunting rounds I’ve seen suggested so far seem to be par with the .357 and the energy delivery is a little bit lower.

 

Honestly both of them seem similar enough that they can accomplish the same task. I prefer the manual of arms of a da/sa revolver over that of a glock 20; if I can find a 10mm platform that I like, I will look heavily at the 10mm as well.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i carry my kimber 1911 chambered in .45 when i bear hunt and scout. Not because i think it's ideal but because it's the biggest i have lol. I'm also not sure I could justify a larger chambered pistol that had a barrel short enough to comfortably carry with all my gear and climber. I am looking for a nice .44 mag, but it would have a nice long barrel on it and I still would probably cc my .45.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Padre86 said:

 

Yes, on average .357 seems to throw slightly smaller projectiles but at a faster velocity and higher energy; I think the hunting rounds can peak at 750 to 800 lb ft.

 

10mm is capable of throwing heavier grain bullets, though the hunting rounds I’ve seen suggested so far seem to be par with the .357 and the energy delivery is a little bit lower.

 

Honestly both of them seem similar enough that they can accomplish the same task. I prefer the manual of arms of a da/sa revolver over that of a glock 20; if I can find a 10mm platform that I like, I will look heavily at the 10mm as well.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

From what I have read the 10mm has more energy than the .357 loaded with the same gr. bullet. You will also fit more in the mag than in a cylinder. You can get longer barrels for the glock if need be as well. Like you mention you can also get heavier bullets than .357. All comes down to what you want. If you want to compare the 10mm to something it is closer to a .41 than a .357.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would carry and sometimes do bring my 45 in the woods....But more often then not it is a 4 inch revolver on my hip...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, TACC said:

Ruger just came out with a 10mm super redhawk

Sent from my SM-G900T3 using Tapatalk
 

I was thinking about the 10 mm but just do not have time like I used to so I am holding off for now....But the 10 is on my list...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not that you probably care but my next pistol is going to be 10mm. I have a .40 and reloading for the 10mm is all the same except more powder. Probably more cartridge than I'll ever need but overkill isn't always a bad thing.

Edited by chas0218

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure if I'm remembering this correctly,  but didn't Ted Nugent take down a wounded, charging (think it was a cape buffalo ???) With a 10mm....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, mowin said:

Not sure if I'm remembering this correctly,  but didn't Ted Nugent take down a wounded, charging (think it was a cape buffalo ???) With a 10mm....

Youre close, it wasnt charging it was coming to eat bird seed out of the ice cream cone in his hand

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1

I find a duck's opinion of me is very much influenced by whether or not I have bread

-Mitch Hedberg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, The_Real_TCIII said:

Youre close, it wasnt charging it was coming to eat bird seed out of the ice cream cone in his hand

Either way it was taken with a 10mm.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not trying to get into a pissing match on weather you like Ted Nugent or not. I was just trying to give the OP some info and effectiveness of the 10mm.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Not trying to get into a pissing match on weather you like Ted Nugent or not. I was just trying to give the OP some info and effectiveness of the 10mm.

We are not in a pissing match, just a snarky comment on my part. No offense intended
  • Like 2

I find a duck's opinion of me is very much influenced by whether or not I have bread

-Mitch Hedberg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No offense taken.  It's been a long ass winter, and some are getting Cranky. We all know how fast a thread can go south. Didn't want my post to start that downhill slide.  Lol

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How I would go about tracking a wounded Bear.

My tracking dog would of course be an "Airedale" the best all around breed of hunting dog on the planet!:pleasantry:

My weapon of choice would be a light short fast handling rifle, my little Marlin 94 in 44 mag with the 16 inch ported barrel firing 300 grain Nosler HPs, using ghost ring open sights, it would fit the bill pretty nice.

If I were forced to carry a handgun it would be a model 29 Smith and Wesson 44 mag with the 6 1/2 barrel firing those same 300 grain Noslers.

Catching up to any Bear with some rock and roll left in it will have the Airedale to contend with while I am filling it full of 300 grain Noslers.

The Airedale pictured is actually one of my dogs owned by a fellow in Canada who has taken several Bear with her.

Al

2018-03-20_101148.png

82388_01_marlin_1894_45lc_16_ogca_eidit_640.jpg

Mod. 29 .44 004.JPG

Edited by airedale
  • Like 3

Serious Dogs For Serious Work

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Lots of assumptions  being thrown out, so I went to buffalo bore and checked the numbers for their heavy outdoorsman loads( buffalo bore is known to have accurate data on their loads ) 

357 - 180 grain hardcast  out off a 3 inch s&w j frame 1302 FPS 

10 mm - 220 grain hardcast from a 4.6 inch barrel Glock 20 1140 FPS

and from a para ordinance 1911 with 5 inch barrel 1201 FPS 

41 mag - 230 grain Keith bullet from 4.5 barrel s&w mountain gun  1310 FPS 

Padre 86 were do u live one of  us guys might  be close enough to let you shoot one of our 357,44 or 10mm’s

Edited by rob-c
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Rebel Darling
      Unsure if anyone's been posting on this topic lately, but up here in 4L, it looks to have been an early hard mast drop.  Tons of acorns on the ground, and I have yet to find a beech tree that's holding.  I've had limited scouting this year, but some staple spots look to be fairly well spent already.
      Anyone noticing similar/different situations in their area?
    • By WNYBuckHunter
      The 2018 deer season is only a few short months away, and we are bringing back a deer hunting contest, The HuntingNY Whitetail Classic! You can sign up for the contest by replying to this thread, sign up starts now and will end at Midnight on September 28, 2018 at which time this thread will automatically lock. In the contest section, each hunter will get their own thread, in which entries should be posted. Contest entries must be submitted by Midnight on January 2, 2019 (Sorry, seasons that run into 2019 are not included in this contest).


      Contest Rules

      -The Deer must be taken in NY during the 2018 deer season (Oct 1 - Dec 31)
      -Deer must be tagged with regular NYS carcass tags (Buck, DMP or Either Sex). Deer tagged with nuisance permits or DMAPs will not count.
      -There must be photos of the deer included in the post(s), they must clearly show the hunter, the antler points of bucks, a clear picture showing the inside spread measurement (must clearly see where each end of the tape measure is touching), this year's tag attached to the deer as well as a contest card (details below)
      -Each hunter can enter up to 2 bucks and 2 does


      Scoring system

      -Each deer will earn 10 points
      -Bucks will earn 1 additional point per scorable antler point
      -Scorable antler points are 1 inch in length measured from the base of the point. Fliers, kickers, droptines, etc ARE scorable
      -Total score of each hunter will be added up at the end of the contest, highest total score wins
      -In the event of a tie, greatest measured inside spread of the entered buck(s) will be the tie breaker (if hunters are tied and each entered 2 bucks, the spread on each entered buck will be measured)


      Contest Card
      With a black marker, make your contest card on a sheet of white 8 1/2" x 11" paper. Write large enough so it can be seen in one of the entry photos. It should include the following
       
      At the top, write - 2018 HuntingNY Whitetail Classic
      below that include your screen name, and the date and location of the harvest (WMU)
       
      The card must be clearly visible in at least 1 photo of deer or that entry will NOT count.


      Youth Division

      There is a separate youth division for hunters under age 18. Exact same rules and scoring as above.


      Prizes

      We will be announcing this years prizes in a separate thread once we have the contest section ready.
    • By burmjohn
      Wow, the 2018 Bow Season starts in just a few weeks, this summer went way to fast!  As always we want to wish everyone a safe, fun and successful hunting season!  Please make sure you keep us updated with reports of your hunts successful or not. 
      The site was down for a day due to our server having some hardware issues, we have restored it to a new server while the old one is being fixed.  During the restore process we also upgraded the forum software. There may be some issues here and there on the site but we are working to fix them, please let us know if you notice anything acting up.
      We wanted to point out a few important threads on the https://huntingny.com/forums/ forums to check out.
      The 2018 "Live From the Woods" thread is up and ready for live action from the woods, 9th year in a row! Post your sightings, stories and pictures -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47908-live-from-the-woods-2018-lets-hear-stories-and-see-some-pictures/
      2018 HuntingNY Whitetail Classic - You can sign up for the contest by replying to this thread, sign up is active NOW and will end at Midnight on September 28, 2018 at which time this thread will automatically lock. In the contest section, each hunter will get their own thread, in which entries should be posted. Contest entries must be submitted by Midnight on January 2, 2019 (Sorry, seasons that run into 2019 are not included in this contest). https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47098-2018-huntingny-whitetail-classic/
      As always there are some amazing trail camera photos up, some real nice deer have been posted, check them out -> https://huntingny.com/forums/forum/23-trail-camera-pictures/
      Be sure to also check out the 2018 Archery Harvest Thread -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47911-2018-huntingny-bowarchery-harvest-thread/
      And of course check out the main Bow Hunting -> https://huntingny.com/forums/forum/16-bow-hunting/ and  Deer Hunting forum here - > https://huntingny.com/forums/forum/11-deer-hunting/
      Hot Topics!
      The Shot That Counts -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47369-the-shot-that-counts-2018/
      Whats for dinner tonight, game recipies -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/23281-whats-for-dinner-tonight/
      Hunter Harassment - Have you ever been harassed? ->  https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47493-hunter-harassment/
      Which hunting weapon and seach do you like the best? -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47874-which-hunting-weapon-and-season-do-you-like-the-best/
      Most wanted bucks for 2018, some great pictures here! -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/46959-most-wanted-for-2018/
      DMP / Doe Tag Swap -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47909-dmp-tag-exchange-swap-donate/
      If you are a Facebook user, please give us a "Like" our Facebook page here: http://www.facebook.com/HuntingNY and help spread the word. The site has grown leaps and bounds since started, there are over 685376 posts as of today! Please remember to tell friends and family about the site, you can even forward them this email / link.
      If you have a hunting related business (ex. hunting store / archery shop), hunting club or organization, or a hunting related website you want to share with members we have opened up a link sharing system here: https://huntingny.com/links Just select the category and click "Add Link" on the right side of the page. 
      If you have any interest in sponsoring the site you can contact us by using the contact form located here: https://huntingny.com/forums/contact/

      Thank you
      Be safe, have fun, and good luck this 2018 season! 
    • By burmjohn
      2018 HuntingNY Bow/Archery Harvest Thread
      Post up pics of your 2018 archery season deer here!

      Only pictures with the associated story will be allowed in this thread. If you want to congratulate someone, please do it by clicking on the "like this" button for the post. There will be no exceptions.

      Feel free to start a new thread if you wish to have comments in addition to posting the photo / story here.
    • By Andy K. 3/2018
      300 acres of mostly wooded property available to lease for hunting on beef farm that grazes, grows grains, soybeans and hay on remaining 200 acres.  Plenty of game and privacy.  ATV's only for setting up stands and bringing out game.  Small group of safety-minded hunters receive exclusive access.  Good neighbors are respectful of boundaries.  2.5 hours from NYC.  $5000/year.  Call Andy at 607-829-5592 or email  kiralyfarm@frontiernet.net
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.