Sorry for bringing up an old thread guys...but I just came acroos the post when I was doing some DeerSearch Googling. I am a member of Deer Search Finger Lakes Chapter.
First, I apologize to the hunter that called and did not get an immeadiate response. I am willing to bet that someone followed up with a phone call within a few days after your shot. We do try to call everyone back.
Most Deer Search members are working full-time and trying to hunt and track for other hunters in their free time. We are always looking for new members...and especially in Onandaga County.
Secondly, I would like to share a photo to help some hunters better understand the location of a deer's spine. I saw the still shot that this hunter posted and I would guess that buck survived.
These are not my photos, but were emailed to me for refrence and educational purpose. Take notice how low the spine is...now add the hide and hair to that!
The straw is where the arrow passed through.
Here is what a shot from a tree stand may look like if it hits too high.
So, there you go. Hope it helps someone in the future. Speaking of help; anyone interested in becoming a member of Deer Search please go here... http://deersearch.org/joining-deer-search/
Thanks.