I'd like to through out a few ideas on why guys had such a tough season. First, the rut. I went back to Alsheimers rut prediction in the Oct. Deer & Deer Hunting Mag. Now looking back on it is pretty interesting. He called for a trickle rut, spread out from late Oct through almost all of Nov, and that's what we had. No real intense periods, which makes for hard hunting. Now, many big bucks were taken this year. If you have a Facebook Acct. look at the postings on the NYS Big Buck Club page, wow, it will blow you away. But in a trickle rut year you really had to be in the right place, right time, which those guys and gals were. Another factor, food. You guys remember how rainy it was this spring, almost into mid summer. That created very lush, nutritious feed deep in the woods. Years like this are always tough when deer, particularly bucks don't have roam for food, its everywhere. They still hit the fields, but mostly at night. (Sound familiar) My last factor could be a little controversial, trail-cams. While I admit, it's the coolest thing to get pictures of those big bucks that live in the areas that we hunt, I wonder how many times these bucks have US patterned, especially if we are not really careful on the frequency that we check our cams, and the scent we leave behind.
On a more optimistic note,a trickle rut doesn't happen two years in a row, so all those bucks that you didn't get this year will be real big next year!!!