I am new on here, so I will try to tread lightly. Here is my take on this subject:
We, as hunters, should be ashamed of ourselves..I have said it before, and I'll say it again...we will eat our own young.
WE NEED TO STICK TOGETHER AS SPORTSMEN!
In all fairness, what difference does it make what you take game with? This crap all starts with one group feeling that "thier" season will be infringed upon. In this case, traditional archers are feeling that the woods would be over-run with crossbow wielding fanatics. Let's be realistic..that isn't going to happen. The people that would buy a crossbow and hunt with it are already hunters that passed the sportsman education test, and maybe have an interest in a new choice of implement. The crossbow does not have a more sgnificant effective range than a compound, so the real issue is the ability to take an animal without drawing the bow.....so what...you could do that in a blind also, and I don't see anyone calling for outlawing hunting blinds. If you feel that strongly about using traditional archery equipment, then do so,,,,it should make the accomplishment of harvesting a deer that much more enjoyable, knowing you had an easier option, but did it the"hard"way.
I have been hunting for a long time, and have heard alot of different whining sessions through the years...Some hunters think that compound bows are unfair also.., some think that tree stands are unfair, some feel that baiting is unfair,[illegal in NY, but acceptable in some other states], some think preserves should be outlawed, some think that waterfowling should not be allwed during an archery season,etc, etc, and on and on....
The issue is, and always has been, we need to stick together and protect our rights as a WHOLE. Archery guys should support crossbows, slingshots,sharp sticks, or any other "primative" implement within the respective season. Just choose to use whatever one YOU are comfortable with. I am pretty sure there won't be a guy with a crossbow perched in every tree.....
We need more hunters with a voice, not less, or worse, a dwindling number who bickers endlessly amongst it's own ranks..the anti's are using this "divide and conquer" metality, and it works, obviously.
If using a crossbow will get a few more young people interested in the outdoors, and get thier butts off the couch,and thier cell phones, and playstations, then we should all support it. As our numbers dwindle, we have less and less voice in the political arena, and when our voice is too meek from infighting and squabbling over petty crap to be heard, or taken seriously, we will lose it all.....
Rich