Vermont added crossbows for hunters over 55 years old. I'm against it, though I haven't seen any direct impact. Yet.
I'm not concerned about changing anyone else's opinion on that matter, but I have MY reasons wanting bow season to stay the same.
I hate change in general.
Bow season IS my "special time". It's special because of the time of year and the weather, and because the deer on a more natural pattern. That makes them easier for me to see them, and kill them. So I'm against anything that would change that. I don't have to worry so much about road hunters, trespassers, deer drives, and all the traffic in and out of the woods that I associate with gun/ML seasons.
When somebody get a crossbow, the first thing I hear from them is "Man, you wouldn't believe how FAR I can shoot with this thing. It's so EASY." That's not what bow hunting is about for me. You can call me elitist, but bow hunting is about getting close, undetected, making a clean shot and recovery. Plenty of people can do those same things with a Xbow, but plenty will shoot too far, wound deer, and hurt the sport.
My friends and I talk about getting lucky during rifle season. We look at taking a mature doe or a buck with a bow as both skill and luck. Every clean kill with a stick and string feels like a trophy. Many serious hunters in VT leave the state after bow season to hunt where there is more deer, or bigger woods. If it wasn't for the peace and quiet of bow season, I would join them.
I'm not saying a Xbow is the same as a rifle, shotgun, or ML, but it isn't truly a bow either. That goes both ways. It isn't as challenging as a vertical bow, and it isn't as effective as a firearm.
I'm not writing this in regards to NY in particular. Just some thoughts from VT, where we don't have nearly as much land, or nearly as many deer, overall.
I just want my chance to hunt deer that are not overly pressured, in the peace and quiet, while the leaves change and fall. If Xbows effect that, then I am against them.