Which deer is it?

[bleonard]

Which one is he? I think it is the second one, comp 2. Due to his enormous size last year (for a 4 point), I think he just kept right on growing. Both 2010 pics are of the same deer. Here are two new ones from this year in the 2011 pics.

[G-Man]

not sure its the same deer....

[shenders]

Each deer is a nice deer. Good luck getting one.

[fisher2]

does anyone else see the 2 drop tines on the lower right 2011 pic?

[wdswtr]

I dont see 2 drop tines, what i do think is like you said the 2010 pictures are the same deer and I also think the 2011 pictures are the same deer.  But the one picture is  too fuzy to be sure, what makes me think this is both seem to have only one brow tine and antler mass and height looks similar.  So my conclusion is all 4 pictures are the same buck.

[G-Man]

top two look to be same deer 2010 -11 . bottom deer is a different one but looks like same one from 2010-11. bottom pic fuzzy but it looks like it is carrying some trash where top deer is clean except for missing brow. most likely brothers or related as same antler config. look like you have two nice ones!

[wdswtr]

Im sticking with my previous post.  Both 2010 pictures have no browtines and both are a big 4 pt.  Both 2011 pictures only have 1 browtineon the same side and both are a 7 point.  All 4 pictures are the same deer.