As a two state hunter, PA and NY, I have seen both sides of antler restictions. I always hunted western NY to have a chance at bigger and better bucks than PA offered. After years of antler restictions in PA, I still hunt NY for bigger and better bucks. I have had to pass on several mature bucks in PA because of the restictions in the area I hunt (4 points to a side). I have seen some of the same bucks for 2 or 3 years that did not have any more points than the year before. There is a lot more to it than age, there is genetics and nutrition as well. If all you are looking for with antler restrictions is bigger racks, save your money up and pay to go on a trophy hunt somewhere. The PA hunters were sold a bill of goods about how antler restrictions would produce more trophy racks, don't jump on that bandwagon too quick, it isn't all it was promised to be!