Score my deer.. Just curious..

[TheTruth2]

So the one on the left I shot this year obviously, the one on the right I shot last year and never really scored either of them because that's not what it's about to me. But I'm just curious as too what you guys would put these at..

[ants]

All I can tell you is that the one on the left is nicer than the buck I shot this year. LOL!

Congrats nice buck.

[burmjohn]

Yeah, both nice bucks

[First-light]

Right 115

Left 125

[Geno C]

one on the left maybe 85"

one on the right 70-75"

i didnt do any math on it, thats just looking at it....

[heatmizzer]

this years buck should gross around 110

[BizCT]

I'm no expert, but I'm not sure if either break 100. Maybe the one of the left does?

[TheTruth2]

Id say personally the one on the left is about 110ish and the one on the right is just under 100

[accman]

I, also, think less than a 100 on each. But it's easy to see they come from some nice gene pools. Real nice bucks.

[beachpeaz]

Agree with the majority above. He would score about 115 give or take:

(this is just guessing based on the picture):

Inside Spread - 18"

G1's - 4" total (3+1)

G2's - 16" total (8 + 8 )

G3's - 12" total (6 + 6)

Main Beams - 40" total (20 + 20)

Mass - 24" total (average 3" x 8 )

Total - 114"

Edited November 7, 2012 by beachpeaz

[Geno C]

Agree with the majority above. He would score about 115 give or take:

(this is just guessing based on the picture):

Inside Spread - 18"

G1's - 4" total (3+1)

G2's - 16" total (8 + 8 )

G3's - 12" total (6 + 6)

Main Beams - 40" total (20 + 20)

Mass - 24" total (average 3" x 8 )

Total - 114"

are you serious with those measurements? LMAO

neither of them break 100" great bucks tho

[BizCT]

Agree with the majority above. He would score about 115 give or take:

(this is just guessing based on the picture):

Inside Spread - 18"

G1's - 4" total (3+1)

G2's - 16" total (8 + 8 )

G3's - 12" total (6 + 6)

Main Beams - 40" total (20 + 20)

Mass - 24" total (average 3" x 8 )

Total - 114"

I'm going to say G2's are more like 12" so thats 8" off right there, and the G3's are like 9" so thats 6" off right there. So 114" less 14" is 100". If you over-estimated any other measurements, its just below 100"

[TheTruth2]

Mehhh regardless, hes going on the wall lol

[Geno C]

Mehhh regardless, hes going on the wall lol

do it up! get em on there

[beachpeaz]

are you serious with those measurements? LMAO

neither of them break 100" great bucks tho

simple math based on a PICTURE. there is absolutely nothing to compare it to. Holding a deer in your hands and looking at a picture are 2 different ball parks. Based on that picture, that is pretty close.

[Geno C]

I'm going to say G2's are more like 12" so thats 8" off right there, and the G3's are like 9" so thats 6" off right there. So 114" less 14" is 100". If you over-estimated any other measurements, its just below 100"

and no where near 20" beams or spread..

[beachpeaz]

I'm going to say G2's are more like 12" so thats 8" off right there, and the G3's are like 9" so thats 6" off right there. So 114" less 14" is 100". If you over-estimated any other measurements, its just below 100"

I disagree, again based onthe picture. I did an average. The left side is larger than the right. he may have 8" in 2's on his left and 7" on his right, so MAYBE an 1" less. His 3"s on his left are definitely 6"! That deer maybe be 105 - 110 because the main beams are impossible to tell how long they are with a picture. other thanthat, I stand by that estiamation.

[BizCT]

If the OP measures the tines, I'm sure somebody will be able to estimate it pretty damn close.

[Geno C]

simple math based on a PICTURE. there is absolutely nothing to compare it to. Holding a deer in your hands and looking at a picture are 2 different ball parks. Based on that picture, that is pretty close.

i want you to score my buck if i get one... your generous

[beachpeaz]

and no where near 20" beams or spread..

main beams on a white tail are typically slighly larger than the spread. He is about 18" wide. His main beams would be 18" - 20" APPROXIMATELY.

[Geno C]

first off that deer does not have 20" beams NOR 24" in mass do you even know howmuch mass that is??

[beachpeaz]

i want you to score my buck if i get one... your generous

no problem. I score deer all the time. I score deer on my trail cameras every year and have been with in a few inches once they are on the ground. Not a hard thing in normal circumstances. he has one view, in a box, straight on. it is impossible to tell how big or smallt hat deer is. he could be 100, he could be 115. that is a minute difference since mass x 8 could be plus or minus 8" alone. The main beams could be 17" or 20" that is plus or minus another 6". etc, etc, etc.

[beachpeaz]

first off that deer does not have 20" beams NOR 24" in mass do you even know howmuch mass that is??

an average of 3" x 4 x 2 is not that much mass at all. In fact, that is super crappy. My buck in my avatar averaged almost 4.5". Go ahead and draw a 3" inch circle. its pretty tiny.

[TheTruth2]

"super crappy" thanks bro

[Geno C]

beach your way off, no offence dude... the angle the OP sent is actually pretty good to get close on the score. those deer are not over 100"