Doc, I would have to agree with you. Growing up, deer hunting was just that DEER HUNTING. I don't know why we have to place restrictions on the size deer you have to shoot. Maybe one of the reasons why the amount of deer being harvested is lower is because we are losing hunters.
I guarantee that NY will lose hunters if they implement an AR state wide. I hunt with 7 other guys from PA and atleast half of them stated that if NY goes AR then they are going to stop hunting up there. I know what some guys think (I use to think the same way but have changed). If those guys quit hunting then that means more deer in the woods that they won't harvest. But now those guys are walking in and out of the woods moving the deer from one location to another. That just means less deer you will see.