The two bucks pictured here were killed last fall. The one on the left was killed by a friend and the other is the buck pictured above, killed by me. Both jaws were taken to the DEC, in Buffalo and aged. The buck on the left was aged at 2.5 years and mine, as noted above was 5.5 years old. I do know that sometimes aging deer can be somewhat tricky but the difference in the two jaws is amazing. I would have NEVER guessed these two at those ages, maybe the other way around. Interestingly, the buck on the left was approx. 140 lbs and mine 173 lbs.
Pretty tough to judge these guys on the hoof!