The only thing the midwest has on NY is genetics and more restricted gun seasons. The debate here is about letting that guy mature, not whether he would ever he would ever grow into a B+C buck. For the guys that say there are no mature bucks in their area: A) they are there- you just aren't seeing them, and you would see more of them if you didn't shoot them when they are young.
If you pick all the low-hanging fruit (less cautious bucks) when they are <4 yrs old, then all you have left are the spooky, smart ones. The midwest, managed-land video hunts are on properties where NO bucks <4-5 yrs old are shot. That way when you get a 5yr old buck that is inherently dumb, hot girls make it look easy to kill them, which it is.