225 lb. Livingston Co. Buck Story

[BizCT]

Same buck 2 years in a row? Freaky

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[nyantler]

ya those G2S are different, silly me!

I loaded the 2015 pic with the same file name as the 2014 pic by mistake and the program changed the 2014 pic... 2014 is the pic I put up a few posts ago. Thanks for bringing it to my attention... sorry for the mix-up.

[Lawdwaz]

ya those G2S are different, silly me!

 

I certainly wasn't comparing two identical pictures..........you can't fool me THAT easy.

 

[Five Seasons]

cool story. that's some balls to hunt only 12' up without cover. You might also consider the biggest trophy is that this buck might extend this guy's life.

[Five Seasons]

Easy to see it is not the same buck or the same pic

zach-tripp-buck.jpg

 

here let me lean back and hold these antlers up real close. man that drives me nuts.

[BuckThornBooners]

NYantler did he get it scored yet?   im guessing  146"  p&Y   

[Marion]

here let me lean back and hold these antlers up real close. man that drives me nuts.

Let's see how far back I can lean to make this thing look like an elephant

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

[nyantler]

NYantler did he get it scored yet?   im guessing  146"  p&Y   

I'm sure he scored it but didn't say... he's probaly waiting the 60 days for an official scaore.. but I think you're score is pretty close

[nyantler]

here let me lean back and hold these antlers up real close. man that drives me nuts.

Don't care if he leans back, stands in front of the buck or takes the pic from 100 yards away... that's a huge buck!

[Marion]

Be sure to check for any ear tags

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

[nyantler]

Be sure to check for any ear tags

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

I'm starting to get how you came up with your screen name.

[BizCT]

I'm sure he scored it but didn't say... he's probaly waiting the 60 days for an official scaore.. but I think you're score is pretty close

i think it's close as well, my guess is a little lower because of those crab claws. I'll guess 142

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Danny]

Beautiful typical 10 and body of a cow...

Man some of the comments accusations maybe rename the site whinersofny.com

On top of the I can't shoot a buck for the first 2 weeks (I'm guessing the everyone gets a trophy generation ) give it a break

Edited October 21, 2015 by Danny

[bowhunt418]

here let me lean back and hold these antlers up real close. man that drives me nuts.

[bowhunt418]

I didn't need to lean back to make a 153" look big....

[bowhunt418]

is any one thinking what I'm thinking? Humm. hope it was part of the river that's south of Dewey hill... but from the discription of river and being that I know this area well it sure sounds like the northen area.. awesome buck either way

[bowhunt418]

How come when someone kills a nice buck there's always people like you that have to assume in some way that they must have taken it illegally? I killed him in 8m.

[bowhunt418]

This pic is also on the 2014 bucks page and it says it was shot on 11/25/2014,,,,,,

[bowhunt418]

It's not the same buck clearly. Here's another pic to clarify of my 2014 buck.

[BuckThornBooners]

it was an inside joke. just trying to rable rouse the 8h guys that can't take a buck the first 2 weeks. so i pretty much said that about every buck taken the first 2 weeks so don't take it personal.

so what did the big ten score?

[bowhunt418]

2014 10pt green 153 3/8

2015 10pt green 139 7/8

[bowhunt418]

cool story. that's some balls to hunt only 12' up without cover. You might also consider the biggest trophy is that this buck might extend this guy's life.

[bowhunt418]

Lol. Was the only tree I could get in and have the wind right. But yes I was lucky I seen him coming and was able to stand up. Thanks.

[bowhunt418]

Let's see how far back I can lean to make this thing look like an elephant

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

[bowhunt418]

Which one? Cause they were both huge. The 2014. Buck was 240# live weight and the 2015 buck was close to 300# live. I didn't need to lean back.