Jump to content

General Hunting Opinion


browningchick23
 Share

Recommended Posts

Okay as far as overhunting, my dad hunted that spot for 17 years and brought a deer out every year. I don't have anywhere else to hunt and I refuse to hunt state land that I'm not familiar with. The spot I'm in is a really good spot, and the other stand is overlooking a clearing and I can't put the blind there unless I sit directly in the middle of it. Which I can't do. I have to make due with what I have to work with.

I'm in northern Jefferson County.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ohh I thought you were bow hunting....and I have fine fly away hair..pain...try Hunter speciality scent away...body soap...actually makes my hair great...and soft...

but IMO that 9 acres is great if your being as quiet and ..OK I'm a scent nut...scent free as possible....9 1/2 is what we started out with and I took deer every year...try and figure out their travel patterns what food sources they are on now and where the doe like to be...I have hunted from folding chairs ...I went to wally world bought 3 yrds or camo fleece.....sat down in the chair wrapped the fleece around me and chair....back to a tree...wind in my face and fine for a whole day...with a gun you have plenty of options to get in shooting position with out being seen....Good Luck

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay as far as overhunting, my dad hunted that spot for 17 years and brought a deer out every year. I don't have anywhere else to hunt and I refuse to hunt state land that I'm not familiar with. The spot I'm in is a really good spot, and the other stand is overlooking a clearing and I can't put the blind there unless I sit directly in the middle of it. Which I can't do. I have to make due with what I have to work with.

I'm in northern Jefferson County.

Cool, have fun with that.

You asked for suggestions, but yet seem not open to any of them. Ignorance is indeed bliss.

Best of luck to you, the hubby, and the little one. May you get a deer ever year for the next 100 on those 9 acres.

Edited by phade
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Phade...she asked for suggestions...OP on the 9 acres being over hunted were given...all she did was reply with the facts as she has lived them...That is not ignorance...I have been told so many times don't do this or that for you'll never get a nice buck they'll all run for the hills and it just isn't the reality that I've experienced..period....not every thing in deer hunting is set in stone...some times...some ppl....not saying YOU in particular...read too many magazines....

Getting nasty because she answered with something you can't imagine is not ignorance

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My response is hardly nasty grow.

My point remains, dont ask for advice and then discount EVERYTHING mentioned by posters here.

She says her dad gets a deer every year. She has hunted the place for days on end, sees squirrels, and then says deer may just move at dark instead of day. She refuses to move to a new spot on public land or even on her nine acres after multiple people suggest it to her after she ASKS for it.Put 1 and 1 together....or dont....fine by me, hence ignorance is indeed bliss. You can try to defend, but you are in quicksand....

My final statement remains true. I hope she kills a deer and wish lucl to her and her family.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know the patterns as I've been hunting there for years. Sometimes I just think they move at night after dark instead of at dusk. Not much I can do there.

Yeah they always seem to go nocturnal after that first gun shot is fired on opening day!

Congrats on the new hunter also

Is your husband on this forum as well?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No. He's not a big computer person unless it's on craigslist :) Oh and Phade - hubby and I take turns as I have 3 different stands on the porperty. I was not trying to dismiss your suggestion, just stating that I'm not comfortable hunting on public land because I have no sense of direction, and don't want to either A, get lost, or B get shot by ignorant hunters. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You have nothing to lose by moving to a new spot on the ground on your 9 acres.

Even something as small as moving 30 yards, or to a new corner of the property, etc. Just grab a chair, your camo, and have hubby snip some branches to make you a new blind there at this spot. I would avoid all 3 stand locations, even if that seems to put you in a tight spot vision wise.

One thing I would do, is drop the idea of putting doe pee on your boots. If you want meat, does tend to be alert at a new, unknown doe, in the area. They simply don't like it. The other would be to get scnet free as possible as mentioned, if you are not already doing that.

Can you ask neighbors to access their property to walk around yours to get to a spot, if you need to? That way, you are not burning up your ground with entry and exit scent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We created a few new spots this past week. I am minding the rain as I am 7 months pregnant and can't afford to get sick right now. So unfortunatley didn't go out at all yesterday. Hubby and I are getting things together in case the power goes out with this storm (that I feel everyone is blowing way out of proportion, but can't hurt to be prepared).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Similar Content

    • By BuckSteady
      New hunter to NY here. Found some public land to hunt, it’s a WMA. I wish I read the regs more thoroughly because I threw up a ladder stand yesterday and today when I was re-reading them, I saw you can’t put temporary stands on WMAs, only on state forests and other such state land. I honestly didn’t know I wasn’t allowed to, I even put my name and license # on the stand. I was going to go take it down tomorrow but it’s an hour drive so I wanted to ask, what do DEC officers do if they find a ladderstand like mine on a WMA? Is this an automatic fine or whatever? Will they just call me and tell me to come get it? Confiscate? How often do officers go through areas like WMAs and check for stands? Any info would be helpful. I’ll still probably go take it down tomorrow, although I have seen other stands up on the WMA, I just prefer to stay on the right side of the law myself. Thanks!
    • By TheHornHunter
      I put up another post a few days ago about the buck I harvested and the favorable weather setup I took advantage of. A member replied asking me to expand on this and how barometric pressure impacts deer movement so I decided to make a new post about it.
      Cold fronts are one of the best catalysts for deer movement and there are  three phases to any cold front which we will discuss later as it relates to hunting. I’ve generalized the wind conditions below which are based on our typical north westerly winds for cold fronts but we occasionally have a NE system come through:
      Just before: winds will typically shift NW to N and barometric pressure will start increasing as temps slowly start to drop During: winds typically still NW to N, barometric pressure is high (30.2+) but typically flattens out as temperatures bottom After: winds shift S to SW, barometric pressure starts dropping as temps increase Before we get to the hunting part I think it’s worth explaining why cold fronts impact deer movement and how the deer react and interpret the weather conditions. Cold weather causes deer to use more energy to sustain which means they need to eat more and thus must head to food more during day light. During the rut it also drives more movement because it’s more favorable for bucks to run around – think about working out on a 90 degree July day vs. a 60 degree September day; I bet you can do a lot more and be more comfortable in September than July. So how do deer react to a cold front? Deer can sense changes in barometric pressure - I believe through a sensor in their ear - and they know if it starts rising that probably means colder weather is coming and vice versa when it drops. This means you’ll see movement just before it hits because deer will sense the pressure rising and will hit the feed to try and get enough reserves to get through whatever is coming. Once the cold is here and pressure is high they will typically continue to feed heavy or if during rut running around like crazy (partly because does are out more trying to eat). Finally, once the pressure starts dropping deer will understand better conditions are coming which I find usually has one good day of movement where deer are out restocking feed reserves and getting their social fix; after the first day of warmer temps I find movement drops off pretty drastically.
      Now to the fun part – how do you hunt them? Most of you know how powerful a October or early-to-mid November cold front can be at getting deer – especially mature bucks – up on their feet and I think any one of the above phases is a good time to be in the woods, although I’ve seen the most movement in #2 when temps are the lowest followed by #1 just before it hits and deer are preparing for it.
      That all changes from my experience once we get past the middle of November - they are still just as powerful (if not more) at driving movement but require different tactics. The cold fronts are now much colder with typically higher wind speeds and the deer are much more run down from already going through the bulk of rut. This translates to much more movement on phase #1 when the first northerly winds come in and pressure starts rising (signaling to deer bad weather ahead and the need to feed) and phase #3 when wind switches out of the south, temps start rising and pressure starts falling (signaling to deer the coast is clear and better conditions ahead). I’ve spent many lonely cold hours in the stand during the middle of those cold fronts thinking deer would be out feeding hard when temps are the lowest but based on my observations they more so just hunker  down in thermal bedding and forage on whatever is close to that. It’s almost like they avoid movement to try and conserve as much food reserves as they can which makes sense given the difference in temps (an October / early November cold front probably bottoms out at 20-40F while later season they will usually be single digits). I think the very low movement characteristics of phase #2 really enhance phase #3 which is by far my favorite time to hunt one of these cold fronts - phase #1 is good too and I definitely go out but I generally stay out of woods during phase #2 and do stuff like pull trail cam cards, put up new sets, etc. Deer are social creatures and become more like humans late season in that they don’t like nasty weather any more than us. Deer will crave social interaction after being bottled up for a couple days dealing with extreme cold so there’s two powerful factors driving movement in phase #3 (need to restore feed reserves and get their social fix). If you get one of these cold fronts from say 11/15 to 11/25 then you add another even more powerful factor and that’s the desire to breed with the tail end of rut. Bucks will finish breeding any does they are locked down with during the cold front but they don’t really go out seeking new ones until weather gets better so you can see some powerful seeking and chasing on the first south wind after a cold front (especially with mature bucks).
      This is exactly what happened on my hunt – Tuesday afternoon the winds shifted NW and pressure started rising so I jumped in an observation stand overlooking a creek bed and rye grass field on one of my properties and saw quite a few does and some bucks (including a big frame 10) hitting the tallest section of grass an hour before sunset. Temps dropped to single digits Wednesday and Thursday – I ended up hunting Thursday because it was thanksgiving and who doesn’t hunt on Thanksgiving (?!) but only saw a few does – I usually see at least one 3 year old buck and minimum of 10-15 deer every time I hunt this property so this was a very slow day. Friday AM was still very cold but winds switched to the south, pressure started dropping, and it was probably 35 degrees by 2PM when I headed out. I went to the closest spot I could get to where I saw the deer feeding in the rye on Tuesday which happened to be in a hedgerow – we didn’t have a stand on it so I put some brush together and made a DIY blind to ground hunt from. I had a 3 year 130-140 class 8 pointer cruise by within 60 yards of me less than ten minutes after I was set up and had constant action the rest of the evening (two mature bucks, two 3 year olds, three 2 year olds and ~15 small bucks and does). I had 8 does in front of me in the rye around 430PM when I saw one snap her head back to the creek bed at the head of the hedgerow I was on and a second later I had my buck in sight at a full run after her grunting like crazy. I couldn’t stop him and ended up shooting him on the run, but it was something I will never forget and is a good example of how powerful the action can be right after one of those brutal late November cold fronts.
      The best stand locations are pinch points between bedding and food or right on a food source (my favorite are green ones like winter wheat, clover, rye, etc. or a cut corn field). I like to sit an observation stand where I can see a lot of ground on the first phase so I can get an idea of where the deer are moving and then I move in on those spots and either ground hunt or do a hang and hunt on that first day of southerly winds (unless of course I’m lucky enough to already have a set hung there but I’m usually not that lucky).
      I hope this helps explain my strategy better and helps one of you put a nice buck on the ground! Definitely let me know if anyone has any questions or has different opinions or experience on the matter.
      --- Horn Hunter
    • By goosifer
      I would like people's thoughts on this. As far as safety (fall arrest) harnesses go, and specifically the part that loops around the tree trunk (cal it the "tree belt"), does the tree belt stay attached to the tree with the stand or stay with the harness on the hunter? I have eight treestands on my property. I hunt it along with a handful of hunting buddies. One buddy who helped me set up a treestand installed the tree belt with a large heavy duty steel carabiner on it. That way, you just have to take the loop at the end of the tether on the harness and clip it in. Convenient, I admit. It has been suggested to me to set up all the stands that way. My thought is that the tree belt should stay with the harness and the hunter, and each time the hunter gets in the stand, he or she is responsible for properly securing their harness to the tree belt (just loop the belt through the loop at the end of the tether first, and then secure it around the tree, that way no carabiner is needed).My thought it I would never want to trust my safety to a belt loop I hadn't installed myself. Also, if you are going to use carabiners, they need to be to climbing specs. If I'm not familiar with the specs of the carabiner, I wouldn't trust it. Lastly, being the landowner, I worry that if someone were to fall and the belt loop that was up there was not secured properly, there could be liability implications. So what do you think, does the tree belt stay with the tree or with the hunter?
    • By Nozzle23
      Hey all, total newbie here. I am going hunting  for the first time and was wondering what people usually bring up the tree stand with them. I was thinking Water, Some sort of food source as I will be in the stand for a long time ,Grunt tube, Antlers,small first aid kit, range finder, binoculars. I will be hunting in northern westchester and upstate in the Andes area. Is there anything I'm missing? I appreciate all responses
    • By Nozzle23
      Hey all, total newbie here. I am going hunting  for the first time and was wondering what people usually bring up the tree stand with them. I was thinking Water, Some sort of food source as I will be in the stand for a long time ,Grunt tube, Antlers,small first aid kit, range finder, binoculars. I will be hunting in northern westchester and upstate in the Andes area. Is there anything I'm missing? I appreciate all responses
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...