Need some opinions....

[TreeGuy]

Well, my gut tells me no but I feel it could be possible. If he ages 4.5 I guess I'll reconsider, but tell me if you think this is the same deer. These are last year's trail cam pics...

[jjb4900]

I'd say yes....

[TreeGuy]

Only thing really similar is crab on right beam and the long hook on the left.....

[Hookhunter20]

Looks pretty close to me. I would think he is the same buck but it's tough to call.

[BizCT]

I'd say yes....

Agree

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[BizCT]

I'd say yes....

Agree

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[TreeGuy]

Well now that I think of it, he had a chunk missing out of his ear... I'm gonna have to dig out the original cam pic and see.... that's a dead ringer.

[grampy]

The brows look similar too. But I hope for you that they are two different bucks. Then you may just kill two GIANTS in the same year! Good luck!

[WNY Bowhunter]

I'd say YES!!!

[HFBPA889]

Look to be the same deer to me.

[HUNTINGS IN MY DNA]

Def 41/2

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[TreeGuy]

The brows look similar too. But I hope for you that they are two different bucks. Then you may just kill two GIANTS in the same year! Good luck!

Already have my number 2 lined up.....

but this guy ( in pics ) has alot of history. Named him the " Vamp " as in vampire. I saw him a handful of times past 2 years but it was always too dark... I always knew it was him because his antlers were obvious even in no light situations. Hence the name vamp, was like he only came out at night. Only saw him in legal light once during bow 2 years ago, chasing a doe, bout 75 yards away. But I have gotten him on camera a bunch. Who knows. It would tickle me even more to know I finally got that bugger. The name vamp has haunted me too long.

And yes, I took garlic and a cross out last year, last day of muzzle... if anyone was going to ask ! Don't judge me

[greg54]

I give it a YES

[DanielT]

I think it's him