I don't fish the island, but I have been in Westchester. The bass are in their post-spawn and is a hit and miss with worms and other soft plastics. You'll get some on those, a couple on some spinners and spinnerbaits as well. I did real good on small profile cranks, namely the Rapala in yellow perch color.
The pickerel are also on the feed in the flats.
Good luck.