Absolutely amazing day out of Montauk, wife and I caught 2 keeper stripers within the first 10 minutes then Caught and released over 30 more before we threw in the towel.
My wife works for the National Park Service, they post signs all over Yellowstone NP not to go near the Bison. Yet dopey tourists, especially from the north east just have to walk up to them to take a selfie with predictable results.
Sounds like your due another trip over. I highly recommend the private tour at Guinness. They teach you how to properly! Pour a Guinness. 99% of the bartenders here have no clue how to do it right.