Jump to content

New Big Buck State Record ?

Homer 55

By Homer 55,
in Introductions

 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 81
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

Geno C
Geno C

Who cares what county it was killed in, it's not like their giving up the location of the tree. People can ask all day where a deer is shot doesn't mean people will find the end location. That's crazy

Geno C
Geno C

I think guys who hide the deer and put it on a pedestal are nuts... There are how many shows out there where guys kill huge deer every year and not only post it but have shows revealing more info you

NY Indy
NY Indy

https://www.facebook...&type=1   This is a fantastic buck!, but, look how far behind the deer he is....It always baffles me why people do this. The deer is a beautiful, once in a life time trop

  • 2 weeks later...
moog5050 Mentor

moog5050

Posted
Posted

The 200" deer I was told was taken a good distance heading east of Rochester. I don't want to spread rumors on the actual town and I'm sure this guy has enough pressure on the area already. Congrats to him! 

 

That's the one Phade mentioned.  Awesome deer.  I would post the photo, but I think that's up to the hunter to decide.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
phade Mentor

phade

Posted
Posted

Why can't someone else post the pic if they have it?

 

They can. I'm not, however. I don't feel it is my place. It was passed along to me in confidence.

 

I entrusted a few people I know from this site with pics of the larger bucks I had on cam this season and not one of them made it to the forum before me and Moog posted them.

 

Some people simply don't want others digging around to find out where they hunt. I know if I shot a 200" buck, I'd be darn sure to protect the location of kill as much as feasibly possible. I don't even know if I would post it online to be honest. People do stupid crap for big deer.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
nyantler Apprentice

nyantler

Posted
Posted

 People do stupid crap for big deer.

 

Yeah like make a claim of a 200 class deer without posting a pic... anyone have a 300 class that they don't want to post either? Every year there are at least a dozen claims and unverified pics of the NEW NYS record buck!... and yet the Luckey and Boyland buck still sit at the top... anyone that doesn't come forward with a potential NY record has no idea why we keep the records in the first place... HINT.. it has nothing to do with the hunter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
phade Mentor

phade

Posted
Posted (edited)

Yeah like make a claim of a 200 class deer without posting a pic... anyone have a 300 class that they don't want to post either? Every year there are at least a dozen claims and unverified pics of the NEW NYS record buck!... and yet the Luckey and Boyland buck still sit at the top... anyone that doesn't come forward with a potential NY record has no idea why we keep the records in the first place... HINT.. it has nothing to do with the hunter.

listen, you are barking up the wrong tree. its not my place to post the pic. did I say it was a record? no. so go pound sand somewhere else where you can cry about not knowing about the buck because its not on your horn porn site.

plus who cares thaf its about the deer and not the hunter. bottom line is today people who blab about their deer have issues. your fb page is full of comments - where was it shot? was it shot on redman rd? and so on and so on. the impact on the hunter may be more than he or she is willing to tolerate. your site is a perfect example actually.

Edited by phade
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Geno C Newbie

Geno C

Posted
Posted

Who cares what county it was killed in, it's not like their giving up the location of the tree. People can ask all day where a deer is shot doesn't mean people will find the end location. That's crazy... Hunting is a touchy spot for some but you would have to have nothing but time and endless contacts to even dig far enough to find where one hunts. Not sure how it is upstate where someone can post a pic and guys know the exact spot by looking at a tree in the background but on the island it all looks the same lol. Same thick crap with a mix of oaks and pine. If people are so affraid of other findig their spots from a pic, don't send it to anyone! Or take a damn pic in the garage or the back of a pickup on the driveway. Give me a break

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Geno C Newbie

Geno C

Posted
Posted

I think guys who hide the deer and put it on a pedestal are nuts... There are how many shows out there where guys kill huge deer every year and not only post it but have shows revealing more info you could imagine then just a pic. Look at Tiffany and lee or the drurys, they have shows revealing just about everything on their farms you think posting a pic is a sin? I get it's not your deer that fine but to think by people asking where a deer was shot they will find out all they need to know on where this guy shot it? Very rarely will you see a guy say where a deer was shot on Nyantlers site and even if they did who to say its not a false town or county. Like I said you would have to be hard up to dig and dig to find out where a deer was shot I don't know who's worse the one who digs or the guys who's so scared for his spots he won't post a deer. To each his own I guess... I know if I was in so much panic about people finding my spots based on pics I wouldn't be on a hunting forum lol

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
phade Mentor

phade

Posted
Posted (edited)

Who cares what county it was killed in, it's not like their giving up the location of the tree. People can ask all day where a deer is shot doesn't mean people will find the end location. That's crazy... Hunting is a touchy spot for some but you would have to have nothing but time and endless contacts to even dig far enough to find where one hunts. Not sure how it is upstate where someone can post a pic and guys know the exact spot by looking at a tree in the background but on the island it all looks the same lol. Same thick crap with a mix of oaks and pine. If people are so affraid of other findig their spots from a pic, don't send it to anyone! Or take a damn pic in the garage or the back of a pickup on the driveway. Give me a break

why dont you contact teebug and jrs. both posted pics or maps and both of them were discernable. jrs posted a 150 in buck pic and I was able to name the landowner and parcel within five minutes. he included info in his post that he thought harmless. best part was he included a map of where the buck was bedding! same with teebugg this week. so its not far fetched at all.

and in small towns its easy to find out where someone hunts simply by seeing their truck parked. if you look at the fb link the comments on that kids buck are ridiculous...arguing about score and then some asshat posts a q about whether it was shot on redman rd. seriously, what if thats true? how would you feel if you were that kid? Id be pissed.

I dont blame anyone for not posting pics. a state class buck, esp. one that is just shy of the top spot, will only make your life miserable.

Edited by phade
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...