what happens when you pass young deer..

[WNY Bowhunter]

Oops, just realized that my math was off in my previous post...57.5 x 2 = 115, not 116. Still, I think he's 130-135 class.

[Karpteach]

Greg, that is a nice deer! If its a 150 or not it's a great deer that you passed on and has grown to a trophy (my opinion).

[WNYBuckHunter]

The difference between Culverts buck and that buck is about 4-5" of spread and probably 8"+ of main beam. Not trying to get inot a Pi$$ing contest on this becuase it is a great buck but helping guys field judge bucks is a major part in QDM. The Velvett 10pt will go mid to upper 130's maybe low 140's but maybe the G-man can clear this all up come october 15th

You could be right, but we wont know for sure without better pics (you dont even have a head on shot) and/or someone putting a tape on him.

BTW, just because someone disagrees, doesnt automatically make it a pissing contest.

[Doewhacker]

"BTW, just because someone disagrees, doesnt automatically make it a pissing contest"

You are wrong! ha

I also didnt see this buck hitting 150 but thats just my humble opinion, he lacks the width as stated, not far enough past the ears. Still one heck of a 3yr old

[WNYBuckHunter]

"BTW, just because someone disagrees, doesnt automatically make it a pissing contest"

You are wrong! ha

HAHAHA my bad.

[ekiert515]

Nice bucks, and i'd put that ten point low 150s. No doubt a shooter

[G-Man]

well hopefully he likes the camera as much as last year and i can get some hard horn shots...velvet does make him look bigger, had him last year guessed around 125-130. he definalty added some mass and tine legnth... be easier to measure him after an arrow is thru its chest