I have used antler ice last year I saw no antlers at all. The first year I shot a nice 7pt ,He was on the trail I was dragging a piece of cloth and soaked it shot him about 60 yards from my stand...got him out and my buddy sat in my stand and shot a nice 9pt later in the day.....I well be using it again this year.....This was the only product I ever saw work...At least 1 year anyway.