card pull from last week how old do you think this buck is

[nyhunter1203]

I think he is a 3 1/2 year old but definately a shooter for me 

[wooly]

2.5 would be my guess but I wouldn't let that stop me if I really liked him!

[ApexerER]

No idea how old but I would shoot him for sure

 

[Merlot]

Definitely a shooter for me. Good luck.

[Berniez]

size depends on quality of food.age just makes the racks thicker. If the one you showed is  a farm country deer 2.5 if big woods 3.5.  The 10 with the 2 picks is definitely over 5 (I have his shed from 2 years ago.)  The buck with the thinner rack is 2.5 as I passed on him last year.   IN any case they are all shooters

[nyhunter1203]

I'm up in the adirondacks with that cam pic more specific warren county and that's why I'm thinking he's 3.5 there is no farm land for miles they are nailing the acorns right now 

[BizCT]

3.5

[LET EM GROW]

pics are hard to judge by.. need a couple good body pics.. id start with 2.5.. looks broad in shoulders maybe 3.5

[QDM4ME]

Really hard to judge from those pics.

Guessing 3.5 

[Core]

If my life depended on it I'd say at least 3.5.

[nyhunter1203]

Here are a couple more might be easier to tell in these he's a big bodied buck and I'll throw one in on the bottom of a 4 point to compare to 

[Buckstopshere]

If he was in my area near the Pa. border , Southern Allegany County, where there is farming is pretty sparse, I'd say 3.5.

[JRod 8G8H]

Nice buck! I agree with Berniez.. My guess 3.5. Good luck

[nyhunter1203]

He's still on a night time pattern though he's getting there I got him at 550 am last week so hopefully we get a chance at him if not we will let him grow

[chiefbkt]

size depends on quality of food.age just makes the racks thicker.

Just to clarify, there is no direct correlation to age and rack thickness. And depending on if you're talking about body size or rack size, there's more to it than just food.