Score him

[Fletch]

Ok this was a buck me and my buddy have several pics of from last season. We had some debate on how big he would go as a typical 8. My buddy did not belive me on how big he would go. Any ideas??

ImageUploadedByTapatalk1348538721.514450.jpg

 

 

G1 9&8 

G2 10&10

G3 5&5

Beams 21&21

Spread 20

mass 11-10-9

 

139

[Mike127]

Not sure why i can't upload pics upright but heres the scoop. 1st pic i passed him multiple times during 2010 season, never found his sheds. 2nd pic was captured about 1.5 miles from where i shot him. When i shot him i made a less than perfect shot, only single lung. he ran about 400 yards so i backed out and retrieved him the next morning. due to poor blood and the long distance i wasn't really sure of his path when he broke his rack. spent weeks looking for the antler with rakes and a few buddies no luck. 

 

The measurements of what i believe to be his slightly smaller side based on the pics i do have of him are.

23 7/8 MB

8 6/8 G1

10 2/8 G2

8 3/8 G3

4 6/8 H1

4 2/8 H2

4 0/8 H3 

3 1/8 H4

His left G1 is 8 7/8 and i gave him a 22" inside spread but  i think he was probably slightly better.

Totaling out to 156 7/8 IF DOUBLED.

[Geno C]

WOW mike! ill tell ya that deer looks strikingly close! his right brow is almost identical from what i can see!

 

theres only one way to know for sure... PM the town if you want and can and ill confirm it with ya since i dont live out on LI anymore... i pegged that deer at 155 and guys said i was nuts. 1 said he was every bit of 150 lol

 

i lost the other pics i had of him, dont know where i stashed them. nice job tho man! do you have pics of the mount??

[Geno C]

i just cant remember if i got that deer on cam 2011 or 2012 tho

 

you def shot it in 2011?

 

[jjb4900]

looks like a brown tag, that would have been 2011-2012 license.

[Mike127]

Sorry no mount i like euros much better 

EDIT haha sorry i dunno why it keeps loading upside down.

Edited September 11, 2014 by Mike127

[phade]

Well done. Well done.

[sampotter]

The 20" are in there! You gave him a score of 154 Popit. I get 152 in my estimate. Follow the math:

G1s 10 x 2= 20 (agree)

G2s 10 x 2= 20 (i say they are 11)

G3s 6 x 2= 12 (agree)

MBs 23 x 2 = 46 (agree)

Mass 36 (32 for me because he is an 8

Spread 20 (sure, why not)

Add it up... Those brows are a game changer. That buck is about as good as it gets for a NY 8. I was struck by how much he reminds me of the buck in my avatar. He would have been right at 150 if was an 8.

 

 

Not bad if I don't say so myself.... I'd forgotten what I had posted but I'm glad to see I didn't embarrass myself, although it looks like Popit was even closer!

 

P.S. If this is indeed the same deer it makes for a pretty cool follow-up Mike127!

Edited September 11, 2014 by sampotter

[Mike127]

Not bad if I don't say so myself.... I'd forgotten what I had posted but I'm glad to see I didn't embarrass myself, although it looks like Popit was even closer!

 

P.S. If this is indeed the same deer it makes for a pretty cool follow-up Mike127!

 

Yea i thought it was cool. waiting to hear back from Geno to see if it was the same area.

[Mike127]

Yup its him. Cant believe i came across that!

[A Sportsman]

Wow that is crazy that it was same deer. Too bad you couldn't find that antler.

That is a heck of a wall you got there.

[Terry]

Very cool!!!

[WNYBuckHunter]

Nice follow up!

[Bone Seeker]

145-155

 

[Geno C]

Dude can belive you found this post either... same deer hands down. Thanks for bringing the thread back! I knew he was that big...

[Geno C]

I said mid 150s and I was right there... 8 points can get big and score that high. There are many shot each year no one even bothers to add in the books. They exist

[Paula]

Wow. Amazing you just happen to come across Geno's post.

[Mike127]

Absolutely right Geno I've got 6 that make the books including another 8 that is in the 150's and none of them are entered nor will i probably ever enter any. 

 

This one comes in at 153 5/8

[Paula]

Mike again you have no face or head, what's up with that? Be proud don't hide

[Mike127]

Haha no shame, i hide my face because of my line of work. the pics around my house and stuff all have heads included lol

 

[wooly]

Mike again you have no face or head, what's up with that? Be proud don't hide

 

Maybe he looks like this guy!

 

[Paula]

Maybe it is him!

[First-light]

Mike works for the town "code enforcement" not a likable guy. lol

[Paula]

Haha no shame, i hide my face because of my line of work. the pics around my house and stuff all have heads included lol

Feel free to post a picture from around your home, of course please include your face. :-)

[Geno C]

Nice buck mike! Dang man, need a partner? Lmao jk