Jump to content

Deer baiting

Naturegirlfromny

By Naturegirlfromny,
in Deer Hunting

 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 121
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

burmjohn
burmjohn

What's scary is how many hunters do not know the laws.

Doc
Doc

Actually farmers have a lot cheaper places to buy feed than Dicks. The stuff sold at Dicks, Gander mountain, Bass-pro, etc. are strictly designed and marketed for hunting/baiting purposes.

BizCT
BizCT

Some guys love apples. They like to bring 20 apples each day to eat while hunting. Problem is that they always wear the pants with the holes in the pockets. So the 20 apples fall out of their pocket e

hb270deermanager Newbie

hb270deermanager

Posted
Posted

Funny thing this you can buy it but its illegal to use it

mentality.It really ticks me off about this.the bottom line here

is its big business and another factor is unless someone turns

people in who uses them the chances of getting caught are

real slim.The property next to ours last where the guys were

baiting got caught when we turned them in.They had to be

on stand and within 100 yds of the bait.The thing that really bothers

me is its illegal to feed let alone bait deer in ny yr round.guys if

you know someones doing it turn them in were all adults here do the

right thing.Its funny you walk in gandermountain the first thing you see

is jugs of sweet mixes and blocks of minerals.Its really a shame guys.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Doc Proficient

Doc

Posted
Posted

Just my opinion...I live in NJ...Baiting has been legal for over 15 years now...I have noticed that many hunters now rely on baiting to attract deer. They have lost or have never learned how to truly hunt...They walk in the woods, see some sign and drop a couple hundred pounds of bait and hang a stand...Does it work, yes they kill deer. Usually does and smaller bucks...I have seen bait sites in the middle of oak flats with acorns raining from the canopy...This past weekend I almost fell out of my treestand when a feeder went off about 60 yds away...Someone put a feeder in the middle of a bedding thicket...No wonder I didnt see any good bucks...

My point is, after many years of allowing baiting...We are seeing more and more hunters who have become reliant on baiting to kill deer...They believe it is the only way to kill deer on a regular basis...The baiters arguments are in suburban areas it draws deer to areas that they can legally hunt... While others cry that they need to use bait because everyone else is using it and changing the travel/feeding patterns..

I do not bait deer...There have been a few exceptions, Wounded Warriors hunt where I was a host and a couple of managed deer cull hunts in suburban neighborhoods...

Does baiting have its place, in some instances I believe it does...Do I think it is necessary to successfully deer hunt...NO...I hope NY never allows baiting...

I agree. I think it is the little side effects of baiting that are the worst impacts on hunting. Some of the things that you have mentioned come to mind. What it boils down to is that it is an attempt to condition deer and make them move out of their natural random patterns just to make them more available for killing and to concentrate deer onto the property of the baiter, away from those that do not use bait. And yes, it becomes a requirement because it does change deer natural patterns for those that don't rely on bait. There is also the potential for starting baiting wars where neighbors try to out-do (out-spend) each other in an attempt to "hoard" deer.

Of course the DEC has different reasons for outlawing baiting that regard herd health issues. But as for myself, I think that a baiting legality has the potential for changing the very nature of hunting for everybody whether you engage in it or not. And that change is not necessarily something that is good for hunting or hunters.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
WNYBuckHunter Experienced

WNYBuckHunter

Posted
Posted

Funny thing this you can buy it but its illegal to use it

mentality.It really ticks me off about this.the bottom line here

is its big business and another factor is unless someone turns

people in who uses them the chances of getting caught are

real slim.The property next to ours last where the guys were

baiting got caught when we turned them in.They had to be

on stand and within 100 yds of the bait.The thing that really bothers

me is its illegal to feed let alone bait deer in ny yr round.guys if

you know someones doing it turn them in were all adults here do the

right thing.Its funny you walk in gandermountain the first thing you see

is jugs of sweet mixes and blocks of minerals.Its really a shame guys.

Im going to play devils advocate here and say that these products are indeed, legal to buy here and use. Its just not legal to use in NY. Its not the store's responsibility to make sure that people use products they sell in the correct, legal manner.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Doc Proficient

Doc

Posted
Posted

Im going to play devils advocate here and say that these products are indeed, legal to buy here and use. Its just not legal to use in NY. Its not the store's responsibility to make sure that people use products they sell in the correct, legal manner.

I agree that they are covered ..... legally. However there is a bit of a moral question in my mind when you consider that they are somewhat complicit in terms of providing materials for illegal hunter activity and most likely fully understand their part in that. One might think that a store that is 100% involved in hunting might consider and be sensitive to local hunting laws and their potential part in those laws being broken. Yes it is a bit of a sticky subject and I can see both sides of the issue. But I will say that if selling those products that are illegal to use here gives them enough income to offset any controversy then most likely it can be assumed that that level of sales does involve significant numbers of local customers that are using the product in an illegal fashion. If that is the case, then they know that they are promoting illegal acts, and simply don't care.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
joe12 Newbie

joe12

Posted
Posted

stores also sell guns. Couldn't you use a gun to kill a deer during bow season (which is obviously illegal)? Wouldn't the store then be selling a product that is contributing to laws being broken? Maybe guns should only be allowed to be sold after bow season. Where do you then draw the line? Stores cannot be held responsible if a legal product that they sell is used illegally.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Geno C Newbie

Geno C

Posted
Posted

i have a question, i went to the hunting expo in the beginning of the year and i sat in for Peter Fiduccia's talk seminar for a little bit while there. I know some guys love this man i happen to think hes a bit of a tool and i wonder how legal he keeps his hunts besides the fact he comes across like he kills the biggest deer ever and is the best.

but anyways, in his talk he stated about baiting being illegal, he then went into saying he uses fake apples and puts them in plastic bags along with some sort of apple flavoring or scent. He says he puts them around his stand to bring the deer in. i almost wanted to call him out on it but i took it in and took it for what it was... Is this legal?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Geno C Newbie

Geno C

Posted
Posted

stores also sell guns. Couldn't you use a gun to kill a deer during bow season (which is obviously illegal)? Wouldn't the store then be selling a product that is contributing to laws being broken? Maybe guns should only be allowed to be sold after bow season. Where do you then draw the line? Stores cannot be held responsible if a legal product that they sell is used illegally.

i mean i wouldnt entirely compare the two but i see what your getting at. however guns can be used in and out of deer season for other uses... bait is strictly for feeding wildlife, its illegal anytime of the year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Doc Proficient

Doc

Posted
Posted

stores also sell guns. Couldn't you use a gun to kill a deer during bow season (which is obviously illegal)? Wouldn't the store then be selling a product that is contributing to laws being broken? Maybe guns should only be allowed to be sold after bow season. Where do you then draw the line? Stores cannot be held responsible if a legal product that they sell is used illegally.

The use of guns is not specifically contrary to NYS laws. The use of bait is. That's where I would draw the line. Note that the stores do not sell illegal guns. I just think that the stores that do business in this state should respect the intent as well as the letter of local laws.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Doc Proficient

Doc

Posted
Posted

Unfortunately Doc, stores could care less of intent as you know. Does intent impact their bottom line?

Yeah, I realize that. It just would be nice if stores made a few decisions based on being good community citizens. I know when I see businesses ignoring negative local impacts I tend to shop elsewhere. Especially if it's a blatent disregard for conservation law (legal or not). I would like to be able to say that I no longer shop at Gander Mountain because of this policy, but basicly I stopped shopping there for a whole lot of other reasons a long time ago.....lol.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
KEVA Newbie

KEVA

Posted
Posted

Selling bait at outdoor sporting stores is one of the most ridiculous things I have seen being done. I imagine Bass Pro and Cabelas do the same? It is an easy line to draw though. Baiting is illegal, stores should not be allowed to sell bait. As to what you want to define as bait, I don't care if the only products they outlaw are those promoted as deer feed. I know you can't stop people from bying bait from farm stores, but that is not the issue. A store that caters to hunters should not be promoting baiting, and by selling bait you are promoting it. You cannot say they are selling it for those who go out of state or for farmers, that is ridiculous. If that were the case, why do they suddenly stock up right before hunting season. It is not just the chain stores that do this unfortunately. The local sportsman store sells some deer feed as well. I don't really think we can do anything about it, other than hold each accountable. The demand for bait is the real issue. The stores are just an insult to outdoorsmen.

By the way, this is a statement from Gander Mountain's site.

"Gander Mountain has joined forces with a host of important outdoor groups, federations, and organizations who share our interest in preserving and managing the natural resources of North America. Together, we strive toward the common goal of bettering the outdoor experience for generations to come."

How is promoting an illegal activity bettering the outdoor experience?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Five Seasons Grand Master

Five Seasons

Posted
Posted

While I was at Dick's a couple weeks ago I noticed a couple young men at the checkout buying big 5 gal pails of some sort of deer feed/attractant. I asked them as a fellow hunter why they buy it. They mumbled something about "building up the deer". Then practically ran out of the store. Why do stores sell this stuff marketing specifically for feeding to deer when it is illegal to feed deer or hunt near or over a bait pile? I am just a little confused! Maybe more experienced hunters can clear this up for me!

same reason they sell crossbows and 3 barbed broadheads. both of which are illegal. You can also buy a pipe or bong to smoke weed which is illegal to use, but it's not illegal to sell and people buy them. My 3rd analogy? fireworks. PA residence can't buy them, NYS residence cant bring them into the state, but yet there's superstores at every exit. lol.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Doc Proficient

Doc

Posted
Posted

how about scent dispersal systems? I use them like my 4 year old uses legos..... Is that baiting? noooooo

Somehow, baiting has taken on the meaning as only being products that can be ingested. At least that seems to be the general opinion. Aerosol products do not fit that meaning.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Doc Proficient

Doc

Posted
Posted

sure is for archery.

Not to nit-pick, but the crossbow is absolutely a legal hunting implement during the regular gun season and therefore has a legitimate reason for being on the shelves of sporting goods departments and other stores. Which of course is the relative point in this discussion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Similar Content

    • mike rossi
      Legal action for keeping fawn in Indiana
      By mike rossi
      Should an Indiana couple go to jail for saving Bambi?
      That's the question surrounding the case of Jeff and Jennifer Counceller, who rescued an injured fawn and nursed it back to health at their Connersville, Ind., home. The couple now faces the possibility of jail time and fines after state officials charged them with a misdemeanor for harboring the animal.
      Jeff Counceller, a police officer in Connersville, and his wife were charged with unlawful possession of a deer, a misdemeanor that punished to its fullest extent could put the Councellers in jail for up to 60 days and cost them up to $2,000 in fines.
      (ABC News) The couple rescued the deer more than two years ago after finding it on their neighbor's porch. The Councellers said the deer had sustained injuries, and they wanted to nurse it back to health.
      "I could feel all of the open wounds all along her back side and she wouldn't stand up," Jennifer Counceller told ABC News.
      They brought the deer home and named her Little Orphan Dani.
      The Councellers said an Indiana Conservation Officer stopped by their home and discovered the deer this past summer. The Indiana Department of Natural Resources wanted to euthanize Dani, saying she might be dangerous and a threat to people.
      "I was devastated. I spent a year and several months nursing her into adulthood, getting to the point where she was able to go out on her own," Counceller said.
      On the day Dani was to be put down, the Councellers said she inexplicably escaped from their backyard. Even though Dani disappeared back into the wild, the Councellers' legal problems didn't go with the fawn.
      The Indiana Department of Natural Resources said it couldn't comment on pending litigation but that it did discourage people from taking in injured wildlife. This case could go to court next month, and if charges aren't dropped, it will be left for a jury to decide whether the Councellers broke the law.
      "No matter what the law is, we did what was right for the animal," Counceller said.
      Meanwhile, the story has caused uproar on the Internet. A Facebook support page has more than 6,400 "Likes" in support of the couple. An online petition to drop the charges already has more than 3,800 signatures.
      Rick on Change.org wrote, "An act of humanity should not be rewarded with a sentence."
      Michelle on Facebook wrote, "They are being punished for having compassion and showing kindness."
      The Councellers' case could go to court next month.
      Also Read

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...