I'm been watching one like that in my back yard...

[nyantler]

I was at the NYS Fair yesterday at the NYS Big Buck Club booth and that is what a bunch of hunters said as they pointed to the Roosevelt Luckey Buck... I just laughed as they looked at me kinda funny...

Edited August 31, 2011 by nyantler

[WNYBuckHunter]

I saw one like that out in my driveway rubbing the velvet off of his antlers on the tire of my Mercedes too.

[5.9cummins]

I was at the NYS Fair yesterday at the NYS Big Buck Club booth and that is what a bunch of hunters said as they pointed to the Roosevelt Luckey Buck... I just laughed as they looked at me kinda funny...

Working or shooting the bull?

I was there Monday and saw butch but couldn't really talk due to my ankle biters being in melt down mode.

[nyantler]

I was working the booth... and for the record... I believe the fellas saw a big buck... just not one that scores 195+... the chance of one of those guys seeing a 190 class buck is very remote... let alone a dozen guys... I actually told one guy that I give him a years pay if he killed the buck he saw and it scored in the 190's typical..lol

[biggamefish]

NY you better watch you and put a disclaimer of fair chase. Because I am thinking I might invest 2-5 grand to get your salary for a year

[Culvercreek hunt club]

You tossing that out as an open challenge on here Joe?...lol NY, fair chase, 190 typical, for your annual salary?

Edited September 6, 2011 by Culvercreek hunt club

[nyantler]

NY you better watch you and put a disclaimer of fair chase. Because I am thinking I might invest 2-5 grand to get your salary for a year

Yikes! never thought of that.. thanks for the tip... ok guys! has to be fair chase to get the loot!

[Localqdm]

IDK, some backyards in the suburbs of Buffalo prob have deer grossing over 200.

[nyantler]

That maybe so.. but the record in NY has stood since 1939.. so I think my chances of winning the bets are pretty good

[Geno C]

ive been watching some real big deer the past month or so but not like him lol

[nyantler]

Like I said.. I did believe that the guys saw a big buck, just not 200 class. Most fellas can see a 120 class in the woods and think its the new world record..lol

[Culvercreek hunt club]

It takes a PILE of horn to make a 170...especially a typical. One think I do believe though....there IS a new state record walking the state every year......just gotta find him.

[nyantler]

It takes a PILE of horn to make a 170...especially a typical. One think I do believe though....there IS a new state record walking the state every year......just gotta find him.

I've been looking!!

[Geno C]

It takes a PILE of horn to make a 170...especially a typical. One think I do believe though....there IS a new state record walking the state every year......just gotta find him.

im with you!

[Doc]

Like I said.. I did believe that the guys saw a big buck, just not 200 class. Most fellas can see a 120 class in the woods and think its the new world record..lol

Yeah, I think I'm one of those guys. I wouldn't know a 120" from a 200". All I know is whether it's a "big one" or not. I've never been too big on using numbers to judge the quality of a deer. They either impress me or they don't.

Of course you won't hear me spouting off estimated live measurements either. Just not my thing.

[Culvercreek hunt club]

My standard for harvesting or not......Is it big enough to justify the @ss chewing I will get if I mount it....LOL

[Doewhacker]

......Is it big enough to justify the @ss chewing I will get if I mount it....LOL

If taken out of context, thats just wrong.