Doc, my first deer was a 1 spike buck. Barley 3 inches. I can still remember every detail of that hunt and still feel the high and rush,more so than a nice mature 8 point I took a couple of seasons ago. I was on cloud 9 for days afterward.
That first deer is a priceless experience, irrespective of size. I think once new hunters experience this, they will understand that the whole experience is a multifaceted affair and big racks don't necessarily = the best hunt.
I remember too the awesome sense of satisfaction when I dropped his meat into the freezer. There are so many potential outlets for good vibes from hunting.