Pretty Scary

[Skillet]

Guys, let's give him a chance to back up his story before jumping all over him. I don't understand why he would make it up.

[ny hunter]

I don't think he is gonna come back with any comments now.

[Geno C]

Guys, let's give him a chance to back up his story before jumping all over him. I don't understand why he would make it up.

that would be a crazy thing to make up... i havnt followed every thread of the kids but i hope he wouldnt lie about something like that. Something of this magnitude could of ended horrific in more ways then one. especially going after 2 guys with guns.

i am surprised didnt hear anything on the news tho, kind of suspect...

[Doc]

I guess I don't know why anybody would relate any stories here. It seems that the first reaction is to attack the person's credibility. Who needs that? The best policy apparently is to just keep it to yourself.

[WNYBuckHunter]

Doc, its not just here, thats the way things work in any public setting. Any undocumented, crazy sounding story is going to attract its share of skeptisim. We have heard a few of these type of stories from Robinson in the past, and even recently. Remember the 91 lb coyote, just to mention one?

I like Robinson, and think hes a good kid, I just think he might exadurate a bit. I dont think Im alone in that line of thought.

[Uncle Nicky]

This story might have been believable, until you got to the part where you engaged the poachers in hand-to-hand combat, but were somehow unable to read their license plate numbers...especially since NY requires 2 license plates on each vehicle....

[growalot]

Really ...seriously UNBELIEVABLE!...why????

Because we all know how guys treasure the thought of going public with a story that ....has one getting their a$$es kicked by a couple of dirt bags and then getting away clean because one for gets the plate # after a very heated encounter..it makes total sense to me now

Now if you really wanted to question the validity of the story...it would be to ask why tell it so long after the fact?...that being said ..

I don't care one way or another it was a good read...brought to mind a few issues..regarding a possible situation and kudos to him posting it...for what ever reason he may have had...worked all the way around ...look at them vultures circling...I'm pretty sure it will be turned into another marathon..pages and pages of foolish "puffing"...have at it.... I'll just read

[Paula]

he will be back, hasn't he told another story or said something that was questioned? he will explain

[Doewhacker]

Really ...seriously UNBELIEVABLE!...why????

Because of his previous track record of over the top tall tales, thats why. YOU can beleive him though.

[Doc]

Doc, its not just here, thats the way things work in any public setting. Any undocumented, crazy sounding story is going to attract its share of skeptisim. We have heard a few of these type of stories from Robinson in the past, and even recently. Remember the 91 lb coyote, just to mention one?

I like Robinson, and think hes a good kid, I just think he might exadurate a bit. I dont think Im alone in that line of thought.

Yeah, I guess I am just one to let people tell their story and unless I have some personal stake or knowledge about it, my conclusions about whether it is true or not are kind of kept to myself. I have no interest in publicly trying to prove someone is a liar. It's just not my style. I tend to just let it slide.

[WNYBuckHunter]

If nothing was questioned on this site, it would be boring. Just sayin.

Robisnon will be back, he doesnt seem to take the skepticism to heart too much, and usually has some explanation for us.

[Uncle Nicky]

I agree, it was a good read.

[First-light]

This is a pretty major episode in a hunting season, why wasn't it posted months ago?? C'mon a bullet goes into your house after a 10 pt is shot on your lawn. He posts all the time here and he keeps silent on this for months, don't add up.

[Geno C]

hey, anything is possible... still waiting to hear what he has to say.

[Robinson446]

Yes it was an imaginary truck. I ate to many magic mushrooms.... Not asking you guys to believe me nor do I ask you if you do, im telling you what happened. And no officer miller and his boys took the deer, not sure what was done with it. Evidence i would guess?

[Geno C]

i would say donation or maybe personal consumption..

[Doewhacker]

So there is no police record of the "event" then?

[Robinson446]

Im not sure there might be. I wasnt able to reach my father that night so I was unable to make a statement without a parent or guardian present (this was said by miller) being i am not an adult... And no nobody got a licsence plate, it happened alittle to fast and tensions were going pretty high. How many times do you hear about a firefighter going into a building and freezing up under pressure or hearing about someone catching on fire and them taking off running? when something serious happens you dont always think straight, you then later say oh coulda shoulda woulda... Not asking for you guyys to belive me, nor am i asking you to beleive me about the coyote, I know what i saw, i was right there, so you guys can try and call my bluff but im not pulling tails, have no reason too. Why would i come up with a story like this? Not looking for enemys on here but i read alot of stuff by you guys that is said out of your butts and nobody calls the bluff or if they do they dont go off like some of you. But to each his own.

[Robinson446]

and i am not a police officer, i dont know why it wasnt in the paper, maybe because nobody was caught for it? im not sure.

[Robinson446]

The barn just up the road was shot just days before too, you can feel free to go ask around coventry..

[Doewhacker]

"Why would i come up with a story like this?"

For the attention obviously. Or you truely are dillusional and beleive it happened.

There were other adults there that would have filled out a report, or the cops them selves would have filed something. It would have made the news.

Other stories you have told include...

91lb coyote that would be a world record

Dog shot by tresspassing hunter that got away with it

City hunters shot a german shepard and brought it to a check station thinking it was a doe.

and I am sure there are more.

[Robinson446]

Oh so your saying i made up my dog being shot and got away with it? You guys are somethings else... Pretty sad when you guys think i would make that stuff up...

[Doewhacker]

Then prove ONE story. You pick

[Robinson446]

And trust me, the last place i would look for attention was with YOU bub.

[Robinson446]

Want me to unbury my dog? Im not sure how you would like me to prove it? would you like to speak to my mom or dad tonight and ask? would you like me to ask my brother inlaw if there was anything else the cops told him when they came back the following day when i got picked up? Help me out here.