New state record deer but is it legit

[phantom]

[phantom]

Congrats  to zack  .

Anyone know the story about this deer . Is it really natural Wild deer or something off a farm  gentically modified to have that rack ?

[biggamefish]

Huh its definitely not a NY state record. Nice deer though.

[Grouse]

Oklahoma

'I thought I was going to have a heart attack': How Edmond hunter killed possible Oklahoma state record deer (yahoo.com)

[wolc123]

Looks like high fence or escaped high fence.  Way too much body mass and antler “junk” for free range from that part of the country (central OK).  Many of the ignorant will be fooled though.
 

Edited November 13, 2021 by wolc123

[Moho81]

Is it just me or does that guy look a lot like @robhuntandfish


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Robhuntandfish]

4 hours ago, Moho81 said:

Is it just me or does that guy look a lot like @robhuntandfish


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Shhhh......still need to have it scored before the press release. 

[phantom]

8 hours ago, wolc123 said:

Looks like high fence or escaped high fence.  Way too much body mass and antler “junk” for free range from that part of the country (central OK).  Many of the ignorant will be fooled though.
 

Says that guy owns  a oil and gas company in the area so he definitely had the means and access to either great hunting land or a deer farm to  shoot a big one like that  i guess . Bet if you look inside that deers stomach it was full of corn .

[rachunter]

Could it be the guy just went hunting and scored a nice buck?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Paula]

29 minutes ago, rachunter said:

Could it be the guy just went hunting and scored a nice buck?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Absolutely possible

[mowin]

40 minutes ago, rachunter said:

Could it be the guy just went hunting and scored a nice buck?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Amazing the opinions before they know any facts.. 

[Lucky118]

Not big enough to be a high fence deer. Or whomever grew it behind a fence  didn't  know a thing about growing big deer. Oklahoma  has deer this big and AG and room to grow them.  

[phantom]

14 minutes ago, Lucky118 said:

Not big enough to be a high fence deer. Or whomever grew it behind a fence  didn't  know a thing about growing big deer. Oklahoma  has deer this big and AG and room to grow them.  

Have you hunted out there ?

 

[Four Seasons]

3 hours ago, blackbeltbill said:

The above sounds probably  true.

Yeah because we all know that guy that made the statement knows a lot about high fence or even deer bigger then maybe 100 inches. 

[Lucky118]

58 minutes ago, phantom said:

Have you hunted out there ?

 

No but there are plenty of videos of guys hunting deer this big on private and public land in Oklahoma with a simple search of YouTube.  I've  had my hands on 2 racks in the 170s and one non typical  180s shot within a few miles of my house where  i have never seen one over 140. So it is completely plausible  this deer is legit. 

[mowin]

5 minutes ago, Lucky118 said:

No but there are plenty of videos of guys hunting deer this big on private and public land in Oklahoma with a simple search of YouTube.  I've  had my hands on 2 racks in the 170s and one non typical  180s shot within a few miles of my house where  i have never seen one over 140. So it is completely plausible  this deer is legit. 

I'm hopeful it is. Too many are proven otherwise. I'm on the hopeful side.

 

[phantom]

9 minutes ago, Lucky118 said:

No but there are plenty of videos of guys hunting deer this big on private and public land in Oklahoma with a simple search of YouTube.  I've  had my hands on 2 racks in the 170s and one non typical  180s shot within a few miles of my house where  i have never seen one over 140. So it is completely plausible  this deer is legit. 

Yea well thats youtube  no way to know for sure from those videos . 

[phantom]

17 minutes ago, Lucky118 said:

No but there are plenty of videos of guys hunting deer this big on private and public land in Oklahoma with a simple search of YouTube.  I've  had my hands on 2 racks in the 170s and one non typical  180s shot within a few miles of my house where  i have never seen one over 140. So it is completely plausible  this deer is legit. 

 

They got big ones out there but nothing like that  fron one i can see i mean this is from there fish and game department .

[Lucky118]

It's  a nice deer but untill it is panel scored by PY  scorers, I have my doubts about  210. It looks like it has alot of deductions.