34 point Giant

[pawle76]

I just got off the phone with one of our neighbors to the land where we hunt who lives there year round and keeps an eye on things for me. When I asked him how his bow season was going he replied oh not too bad ! He then directed me to his face book page to have a look see at his "halfway decent" buck. This is what I saw:

 

 

 

 

It was taken near Rhinebeck

Edited November 1, 2013 by pawle76

[IronBucks]

I would have passed.  Next year that thing could have a good rack. 

 

[Geno C]

I just got the text also an hour ago said to be killed in Columbia county? Any word

[Cabin Fever]

Good God...

[growalot]

Hey I would have passed too....passed right out!...lol

[pawle76]

I just got the text also an hour ago said to be killed in Columbia county? Any word

All he told me was he got it near rhinebeck so it very well could've been columbia county. I didn't want to ask him at the time about it but isn't there some type of hunting "preserve" over there ?

[88GW]

This showed up on another forum and they are claiming it was a high fence hunt.  North East Whitetail in Elizaville NY.  $3,000 plus to hunt there, 250 fenced acres.

[pawle76]

This showed up on another forum and they are claiming it was a high fence hunt.  North East Whitetail in Elizaville NY.  $3,000 plus to hunt there, 250 fenced acres.

yeah I thought so. 

[Nomad]

This showed up on another forum and they are claiming it was a high fence hunt. North East Whitetail in Elizaville NY. $3,000 plus to hunt there, 250 fenced acres.

Well the fact I can't see a tag on it ,lends me to think preserve deer as well.

[burmjohn]

This seems like a re-run of what happened last year

 

Remember, the guy that did the high fence hunt, didn't gut it there, dragged it to his woods, gutted it, tagged it. 

 

http://huntingny.com/forums/topic/11984-potentential-new-state-record-was-a-hoax-it-was-a-high-fence-farm-deer/

[pawle76]

When I first saw the pic on face book the first thing I thought was that's gotta be a farm raised deer. I know there are some nice bucks on that side of the hudson but that is ridiculous.

[pawle76]

This seems like a re-run of what happened last year

 

Remember, the guy that did the high fence hunt, didn't gut it there, dragged it to his woods, gutted it, tagged it. 

 

http://huntingny.com/forums/topic/11984-potentential-new-state-record-was-a-hoax-it-was-a-high-fence-farm-deer/

 

Now to be fair I know this person and as far as I know I doubt he would try to pass this buck off as a new record or some other hoax. So lets not start the character assassination just yet.

[burmjohn]

Now to be fair I know this person and as far as I know I doubt he would try to pass this buck off as a new record or some other hoax. So lets not start the character assassination just yet.

 

Nah, just saying it seems like a re-run.

 

I don't know this guy from a hole in the wall. 

[mbucks27]

I saw two different pics of this buck on Facebook with two different people holding it.  i also heard it was shot hit by a car in Greene county lol. I'm not believing anything i hear about this one.  Too many rumors going around.

 

John

[DROpTINE]

i hope it is a fair chase deer....beautiful rack... face looks a little old, so maybe, just maybe, we can see a legit giant this year

[steve863]

And that's why some of us are against stupid rules like AR's.  When we kill our spikes and forkhorns and then post pictures on forums, NO one will accuse us of killing them in a pen.  LOL   Of course some will accuse us of killing the dumbest deer in the woods, but hey, at least the bugger had his freedom during his 1.5 years of life.  LOL

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[burmjohn]

LOL love all the different stories. Its getting more legit by the second. Post links to these other reports please.

Sent from my LG-VS980 using Tapatalk

[Five Seasons]

&*#$ me sideways!

[moog5050]

Too bad the tines are so short or he would have scored well.  Be tough not to stare at that rack.

[Danny]

So it's your neighbor but a different county, and a possible high fence can hunt? Ya neighbor seeing any mountain lions too?

[ELMER J. FUDD]

It looks like it hasn't even been field dressed.

[Culvercreek hunt club]

It looks like it hasn't even been field dressed.

 

 

They are doing a full body mount so they took it all out through the bung hole.

Edited November 1, 2013 by Culvercreek hunt club

[growalot]

Good God!...You guys have run down the list....where's the... it was photo shopped?....

[Cabin Fever]

They are doing a full body mount so they took it all out through the bung hole.

[Culvercreek hunt club]

I gotta be honest. I don't think I could keep it together enough to get an arrow away on a deer like that.