First post...first decent buck on cam

[germs087]

I know it's a bit dark but what are your thoughts on this guy?

[BigVal]

Nice buck! I'd let an arrow fly 

[BizCT]

I would


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[germs087]

Just got access to it half way through the season last year. Any thoughts on age?

[BBDEric]

2.5 good basket rack deff a shooter for me. We're in nys not mid west. Out to its ears is a good buck in ny

[Zag]

6 minutes ago, germs087 said:

Just got access to it half way through the season last year. Any thoughts on age?

I think age/size really depends on the area your hunting. I'm after one that I believe is 4 1/2 based on last yr and this yrs pics, but if he was from another area I hunt he would be as big as a 3 1/2. 

[germs087]

9J Busti area

[Rockspek]

9 hours ago, germs087 said:

 

I know it's a bit dark but what are your thoughts on this guy?

 

I had a buck look very similar to this guy on cam last year.  Except he was a 7 point but very tall like this.  This year I got him on cam only once and he improved significantly.  However, if I saw yours or mine last year(or this year) I would go for either one.  There are other hunters out there and cars that hit deer all the time.  Hope you get a chance to meet him.

[GreeneHunter]

A Shooter !

[ny hunter]

Nice good luck with him

[Core]

Looks pretty big to me!

[LET EM GROW]

Shooter to many folks!! looks like a solid 2.5 yr old. Nice looking deer

[WNY-Hunter]

Looks like some real nice backstraps !!

[moog5050]

The only opinion that really matters is yours.  Good luck with him.

[bugsNbows]

Shoot that sucker. Ya can't eat bone! 

[BuckThornBooners]

[chas0218]

17 minutes ago, Odorless said:

Your call but I agree with the above. 

[grampy]

Every deer is a good one! What makes "YOU" happy is all that matters. Best of luck this season!

[JRod 8G8H]

LOL 2.5 year old for sure. Nice deer.. that's a good buck here in WNY.. shoot him!! Best of luck

[The_Real_TCIII]

Wasn't the Hanson buck 3.5 years old? Do you really want to kill a potential world record buck one year too soon??


Im Kidding, kill that buck and eat him

[Arcade Hunter]

I think I would!   Good luck to you tomorrow!

[germs087]

I am having a hard time with this guy. Some pictures look good others just decent. Why can't they ever just pose and smile for the camera?

[germs087]

I am having a hard time with this guy. Some pictures look good others just decent. Why can't they ever just pose and smile for the camera?