Recommended Posts

I'm looking for feedback on which pistol cartridges are ideal for dispatching black bear and deer.

I need a good sidearm to carry along for tracking and dispatching wounded game.  I will always rely on a rifle or shotgun if I believe the animal's wounds are marginal.  But for those situations where the animal's wounds are fatal but it life still lingers, I would like a reliable, widely available and effective pistol cartridge for dispatching it.

 

The cartridges I am considering for this application:

  • .357 magnum
  • 10mm auto
  • .44 magnum
  • .41 magnum
  • .454 casull

I would prefer a revolver for its simplicity and reliability for shooting big cartridges.  As well, I really don't see the need for anything more than 6-8 shot capacity for this use.  That said, I would consider a semi-auto if the case for 10mm's usefulness can be made.  

With regards to the magnum cartridges and bears: I've seen a lot of people preach that "bigger is better."  And while I acknowledge that something like a .44 magnum or .454 casull are well-regarded for killing big game, I would prefer a cartridge that is adequate for handling black bear rather than one that is overkill, if that makes sense.  I have given .357 magnum much consideration for this reason.

I would like to hear feedback from those that have experience with these cartridges, or perhaps others that I haven't considered.  

Edited by Padre86

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

.45 LC (Nosler 250 gr. JHP) in a Judge would do the job just fine... IMHO


Bad day of hunting beats a good day at the office

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

would say most calipers would work for this at a close range to dispatch.  except like a 22 .   .357 or .44 is def an all around cartridge for something like that.  Like bkln above i also carry a judge and have taken it during gun season loaded with .45 or .410 slugs. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

44 and 357 mag, are a popular choices, that Deer Search members use to dispatch wounded deer and bear.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Buddy of mine swears by his G20 (10mm) and he's got some really fat ninja bears on his hunting land.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Robhuntandfish said:

would say most calipers would work for this at a close range to dispatch.  except like a 22 .   .357 or .44 is def an all around cartridge for something like that.  Like bkln above i also carry a judge and have taken it during gun season loaded with .45 or .410 slugs. 

Watch the .410 slugs and dec.  

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

True.  Good point.  I only took pistol twice and I loaded .45 in it.  I took it another time and never thought of that.  As all I had in pack was the  410s. Good catch and thanks.  

Never use it to hunt just had it as a finish if needed, and luckily didn't have to use it.  But am sure Dec still wouldn't like that.  .45it is. 

Edited by Robhuntandfish

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a 10mm Glock 29 and consider it to be just about the perfect solution to a problem that doesn’t really exist. I carried it for years with other handguns but really if I needed to put down a deer I’m using my rifle not the pistol. The sidearm I carry the most is an sr22 Ruger. Weighs nothing accurate as hell and would do a perfect job dispatching a downed buck that I don’t want to try and slit its throat.

I bought a scandium framed 329 S&W and it was great to carry but not fun to shoot.

In my opinion carrying a sidearm for the purpose of dispatching wounded game isn’t worth it. If you want it for protection Incase you get separated from your rifle I would suggest a small 9mm semi.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd look at a 45 long colt, 454. And 45-70 gov.  The 44.mag is possible with proper bullet but other calibers are buy and shoot. No extra homemade reload needed.


I've hunted almost everyday of my life.. the rest have been wasted!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


In my opinion carrying a sidearm for the purpose of dispatching wounded game isn’t worth it. If you want it for protection Incase you get separated from your rifle I would suggest a small 9mm semi.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


In my experience and the experiences of other trackers, it is worth having a pistol, or at least the option of one. I’ve trudged through some pretty atrocious terrain where a long gun is quite a burden to carry around.

This isn’t a protection pistol but rather for dispatching wounded game; that’s why I’m looking heavily at the magnum pistol cartridges. 9mm isn’t even a consideration for my purposes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I own both 357mag and 44mag i feel either well do the job of an easy and quick kill of a wounded animal.Also well fend off any attack of animal in these NY woods......I also like revolvers more then semi auto's again I own both....Good luck....Let us know which you decide on...

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
53 minutes ago, Padre86 said:

 


In my experience and the experiences of other trackers, it is worth having a pistol, or at least the option of one. I’ve trudged through some pretty atrocious terrain where a long gun is quite a burden to carry around.

This isn’t a protection pistol but rather for dispatching wounded game; that’s why I’m looking heavily at the magnum pistol cartridges. 9mm isn’t even a consideration for my purposes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Just curios, have you shot any of the bigger calibers ? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

I'd get a 357 mag and 6" barrel and a nice chest rig and go have fun. Can shoot 38 special to plink as a bonus for fun.

  • Like 2

Give it a name, apply human sentiment, and its no longer a wild animal its a Disney character.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just curios, have you shot any of the bigger calibers ? 


I have not. That’s why I’m seeking feedback. I’d prefer to go with a cartridge that is suitable rather than one that is overkill.

If I can get the job done without having to deal with a .44 magnum recoil, that would suit me just fine.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, Padre86 said:

 


I have not. That’s why I’m seeking feedback. I’d prefer to go with a cartridge that is suitable rather than one that is overkill.

If I can get the job done without having to deal with a .44 magnum recoil, that would suit me just fine.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

 

Well then a 357 with a heavy for caliber bullet (170 grains on up ) will do you just fine.a  gp- 100  will handle any hot load you can throw at it, plus it’s heavy enough to soke up  some recoil. And I second what dinsdal said about a chest rig.. 

Edited by rob-c
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


In my experience and the experiences of other trackers, it is worth having a pistol, or at least the option of one. I’ve trudged through some pretty atrocious terrain where a long gun is quite a burden to carry around.

This isn’t a protection pistol but rather for dispatching wounded game; that’s why I’m looking heavily at the magnum pistol cartridges. 9mm isn’t even a consideration for my purposes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

If you’re not carrying a long gun the sidearm becomes the main gun and that changes my answer, kinda. A light short carbine chambered for a real cartridge still has my vote. Every tracker that tracks with dogs that I know carry’s a 22lr or 22mag revolver. My wife would got to a single action revolver in 22mag for dispatching wounded critters.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well then a 357 with a heavy for caliber bullet (170 grains on up ) will do you just fine.a  gp- 100  will handle any hot load you can throw at it, plus it’s heavy enough to soke up  some recoil. And I second what dinsdal said about a chest rig.. 


Thanks. And yeah, I agree with you and dinsdal that a good chest rig will be in order as well. I’ve been looking at diamond custom’s guide chest rig....it’s pricey but I like how it can be customized and arranged to a specific user’s needs. I’ve heard a lot of good reviews too.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have hunted with both 357 and 44 mag handguns and I like both calibers a lot but with the criteria you have come up with I would strongly lean to a 44 mag. From what I have experienced the 44 mag has a pretty big edge over the 357 when it comes to killing power. Have killed Deer and Hogs with assorted handguns, never personally taken a Bear myself but if I were in a situation where it comes to putting the finisher on a wounded one with a handgun there would be no messing around, I would want that big edge the 44 has to be on the safe side.

Al

 


Serious Dogs For Serious Work

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have hunted with both 357 and 44 mag handguns and I like both calibers a lot but with the criteria you have come up with I would strongly lean to a 44 mag.
Al
 



Al, I’ve seen similar advice on other websites. I do understand that .44
Mag offers much better energy delivery. And I’ve seen a lot of people recommend it for bear (brown) defense and handgun hunting for that reason.

But I’ve heard it also kicks quite hard. I’m sure I could learn to deal with the greater recoil, but all other things being equal, I will likely shoot better and faster with a lower recoil cartridge.

The .44 mag platforms also seem heavier, especially those in 4”-6” barrels. I know the added heft will help tame the recoil, but a pistol of lower weight would be my preference, especially for long foot movements.

So I realize there are other cartridges that are more capable for such uses. I’m trying to find one that is good enough, while also giving me lighter recoil and better portability. I’ve seen several Chuckhawks articles describe .357 as a minimum, but acceptable, brown bear defensive cartridge. If it’s good enough for handling a brown bear, albeit in a defensive manner, should it not be more than adequate for a wounded black bear?

If i think the animal I’m after is only marginally wounded, I’m not going to bother with a pistol at all.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Padre86 said:

 

 


Al, I’ve seen similar advice on other websites. I do understand that .44
Mag offers much better energy delivery. And I’ve seen a lot of people recommend it for bear (brown) defense and handgun hunting for that reason.

But I’ve heard it also kicks quite hard. I’m sure I could learn to deal with the greater recoil, but all other things being equal, I will likely shoot better and faster with a lower recoil cartridge.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

 

Maybe you have watched too many "dirty Harry" movies.   I too was a little scared of the .44 magnum prior to firing one.   That caused me to anticipate the recoil, flinch and cleanly miss the target paper at 50 yards with my first shot.   Had that shot been at a wounded bear, I may have been eaten.  The recoil turned out to be very tame, compared to some other weapons I have fired with a pistol grip, including a short barreled 12 gauge slug gun.    Lots of folks are scared of the recoil of a .44 magnum, just because the name sounds tough.    Unless you are a small girl, I would recommend giving one a try.   You can always visit a range where someone will let you try one before making the purchase.  After I felt that "wimpy" recoil on my first shot, the next one struck right on target.           

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My choice that will surely cause some controversy but I have shot deer with it with good results. It is also a fun caliber to shoot and more than enough for self defense. I went to this from a .357 magnum because the ballistics  were comparable,  the recoil/noise are substantially less and I didn't want to go to a 10mm. Would I shoot a bear with it?....probably not but up close it should be effective: the .40 s&w.

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wolc123, I probably will test fire a .44 magnum just to get a feel for it. That said, the recoil on it (especially for hunting loads) seems significant based on the reviews and videos I’ve seen.

Like I said earlier, I know i could deal with the recoil, but if I could accomplish the same goal without that recoil that would be my preference.

It doesn’t seem that this cartridge is one that I’d want to practice extensively with. I’ve heard a lot of comments about how shooting more than a few rounds can be uncomfortable. I place a high priority on shoot-ability for target practice.

Moreover the greater the recoil, the longer it takes for me to re-acquire a sight picture for follow up shots.

I’m certainly not afraid to handle something like a .44 magnum. I’ve dealt with big recoil before. But I do question if it will be as practical for what I’m trying to do.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Rebel Darling
      Unsure if anyone's been posting on this topic lately, but up here in 4L, it looks to have been an early hard mast drop.  Tons of acorns on the ground, and I have yet to find a beech tree that's holding.  I've had limited scouting this year, but some staple spots look to be fairly well spent already.
      Anyone noticing similar/different situations in their area?
    • By WNYBuckHunter
      The 2018 deer season is only a few short months away, and we are bringing back a deer hunting contest, The HuntingNY Whitetail Classic! You can sign up for the contest by replying to this thread, sign up starts now and will end at Midnight on September 28, 2018 at which time this thread will automatically lock. In the contest section, each hunter will get their own thread, in which entries should be posted. Contest entries must be submitted by Midnight on January 2, 2019 (Sorry, seasons that run into 2019 are not included in this contest).


      Contest Rules

      -The Deer must be taken in NY during the 2018 deer season (Oct 1 - Dec 31)
      -Deer must be tagged with regular NYS carcass tags (Buck, DMP or Either Sex). Deer tagged with nuisance permits or DMAPs will not count.
      -There must be photos of the deer included in the post(s), they must clearly show the hunter, the antler points of bucks, a clear picture showing the inside spread measurement (must clearly see where each end of the tape measure is touching), this year's tag attached to the deer as well as a contest card (details below)
      -Each hunter can enter up to 2 bucks and 2 does


      Scoring system

      -Each deer will earn 10 points
      -Bucks will earn 1 additional point per scorable antler point
      -Scorable antler points are 1 inch in length measured from the base of the point. Fliers, kickers, droptines, etc ARE scorable
      -Total score of each hunter will be added up at the end of the contest, highest total score wins
      -In the event of a tie, greatest measured inside spread of the entered buck(s) will be the tie breaker (if hunters are tied and each entered 2 bucks, the spread on each entered buck will be measured)


      Contest Card
      With a black marker, make your contest card on a sheet of white 8 1/2" x 11" paper. Write large enough so it can be seen in one of the entry photos. It should include the following
       
      At the top, write - 2018 HuntingNY Whitetail Classic
      below that include your screen name, and the date and location of the harvest (WMU)
       
      The card must be clearly visible in at least 1 photo of deer or that entry will NOT count.


      Youth Division

      There is a separate youth division for hunters under age 18. Exact same rules and scoring as above.


      Prizes

      We will be announcing this years prizes in a separate thread once we have the contest section ready.
    • By burmjohn
      Wow, the 2018 Bow Season starts in just a few weeks, this summer went way to fast!  As always we want to wish everyone a safe, fun and successful hunting season!  Please make sure you keep us updated with reports of your hunts successful or not. 
      The site was down for a day due to our server having some hardware issues, we have restored it to a new server while the old one is being fixed.  During the restore process we also upgraded the forum software. There may be some issues here and there on the site but we are working to fix them, please let us know if you notice anything acting up.
      We wanted to point out a few important threads on the https://huntingny.com/forums/ forums to check out.
      The 2018 "Live From the Woods" thread is up and ready for live action from the woods, 9th year in a row! Post your sightings, stories and pictures -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47908-live-from-the-woods-2018-lets-hear-stories-and-see-some-pictures/
      2018 HuntingNY Whitetail Classic - You can sign up for the contest by replying to this thread, sign up is active NOW and will end at Midnight on September 28, 2018 at which time this thread will automatically lock. In the contest section, each hunter will get their own thread, in which entries should be posted. Contest entries must be submitted by Midnight on January 2, 2019 (Sorry, seasons that run into 2019 are not included in this contest). https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47098-2018-huntingny-whitetail-classic/
      As always there are some amazing trail camera photos up, some real nice deer have been posted, check them out -> https://huntingny.com/forums/forum/23-trail-camera-pictures/
      Be sure to also check out the 2018 Archery Harvest Thread -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47911-2018-huntingny-bowarchery-harvest-thread/
      And of course check out the main Bow Hunting -> https://huntingny.com/forums/forum/16-bow-hunting/ and  Deer Hunting forum here - > https://huntingny.com/forums/forum/11-deer-hunting/
      Hot Topics!
      The Shot That Counts -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47369-the-shot-that-counts-2018/
      Whats for dinner tonight, game recipies -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/23281-whats-for-dinner-tonight/
      Hunter Harassment - Have you ever been harassed? ->  https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47493-hunter-harassment/
      Which hunting weapon and seach do you like the best? -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47874-which-hunting-weapon-and-season-do-you-like-the-best/
      Most wanted bucks for 2018, some great pictures here! -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/46959-most-wanted-for-2018/
      DMP / Doe Tag Swap -> https://huntingny.com/forums/topic/47909-dmp-tag-exchange-swap-donate/
      If you are a Facebook user, please give us a "Like" our Facebook page here: http://www.facebook.com/HuntingNY and help spread the word. The site has grown leaps and bounds since started, there are over 685376 posts as of today! Please remember to tell friends and family about the site, you can even forward them this email / link.
      If you have a hunting related business (ex. hunting store / archery shop), hunting club or organization, or a hunting related website you want to share with members we have opened up a link sharing system here: https://huntingny.com/links Just select the category and click "Add Link" on the right side of the page. 
      If you have any interest in sponsoring the site you can contact us by using the contact form located here: https://huntingny.com/forums/contact/

      Thank you
      Be safe, have fun, and good luck this 2018 season! 
    • By burmjohn
      2018 HuntingNY Bow/Archery Harvest Thread
      Post up pics of your 2018 archery season deer here!

      Only pictures with the associated story will be allowed in this thread. If you want to congratulate someone, please do it by clicking on the "like this" button for the post. There will be no exceptions.

      Feel free to start a new thread if you wish to have comments in addition to posting the photo / story here.
    • By Andy K. 3/2018
      300 acres of mostly wooded property available to lease for hunting on beef farm that grazes, grows grains, soybeans and hay on remaining 200 acres.  Plenty of game and privacy.  ATV's only for setting up stands and bringing out game.  Small group of safety-minded hunters receive exclusive access.  Good neighbors are respectful of boundaries.  2.5 hours from NYC.  $5000/year.  Call Andy at 607-829-5592 or email  kiralyfarm@frontiernet.net
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.