Your Biggest NY Buck

[JJNY]

Pic 1

Best Buck with the Bow - 8pt

Halloween 1997

Cohocton, NY

Killed just after 7 am at 30 Yards with my old Bear Whitetail II

After I hit it it ran back at me, right under the tree and dropped dead 15 yards behind the tree.

 

Pic 2

Killed this 8pt out of the same Tree 2 Years later at only 7 Yards. Arrow actually pinned him to a Tree for a quick second.

 

Pic 3

Best Buck with the Gun - 7pt

Opening Day 2011

Avoca, NY

Killed at 3 pm

 

[crappyice]

One year prior to Biz - 2006 also in Putnam(3n) - my first harvest of any big game.

[ncountry]

Killed this 8pt out of the same Tree 2 Years later at only 7 Yards. Arrow actually pinned him to a Tree for a quick second

Nice!... I killed a 7,8,9,10, and another 8 out of the same tree between Nov 9-11 different years. I think the same doe came in heat every year at the same time and led them past my stand... Worked 5 years in a row, I never stepped foot into this spot until Nov 9-11. I think someone killed my doe because it hasn't worked for 4-5 years now...damit...lol

[MACHINIST]

Here is mine,he is on the right.Taxidermist said around 135 and he weighed 175 pounds dress.The buck on the right weighed in at 240 dressed,biggest deer the butcher has ever had still to this day.All three were killed in oswego county NY

 

 

Edited September 5, 2013 by MACHINIST

[132 eight pointer]

My one and only big buck.Opening day of firearm in the southern zone (8F) 2005. Had the antlers scored after  they were mounted, 132 gross / 130 net. I regret not having a full head mount done but I didn't have the dinero at the time.My buddy likes to tell me when he comes over how I should have had a mount done.I also didn't have time to weigh him but he is the biggest bodied deer I have ever killed too.Nice bucks everyone!

Edited September 5, 2013 by 132 eight pointer

[New York Hillbilly]

Nice bucks!!!! Giving me the itch!

Hey...ncountry, I just noticed your just down the street from me. I stayed in Red Mills all summer since moving up this way. I guess there are deer up here after all, judging from your wall, Nice!

[Chumleyhunts]

 

My best (and only) NY buck. Been hunting up here a couple years, just moved here in May from Pa. Livingston County buck first day 2012.

[WhitetailAddict11]

My best. Taken last year with a bow.

[meatmuzzy]

My biggest by far taken last year in Suffolk County with the bow.  Grossed 138".

[crappyice]

That's a slammer, meatmuzzy - what's he got a child-proof horn on his right?

[PWGUNNY]

My biggest was the 9 pointer I shot near Cobleskill.  I took him with a 12ga Sabot slug from 80 yds.

[NYbuck50]

 

My biggest is one of these. All taken the last 5 years  With how my scouting has gone this year, i will hopefully well surpass my biggest this season, as ive really been working on scouting specifically for mature buck sign instead of deer sign

[meatmuzzy]

That's a slammer, meatmuzzy - what's he got a child-proof horn on his right?

 

LOL yea he's got a unique "acorn" tip on his right G3.

[Geno C]

Some

Nice bucks boys!!

I'd call meatmuzzys buck the acorn buck lol

[dirt_a_KISS]

166 gross, 141 net, 2006

1876_45973741361_6540_n.jpg

164 gross, 153 net, 2008

645_45971551361_6868_n.jpg

HOLY COW!!! Those deer were monsters.

[genesee_mohican]

Some real nice deer on here by all.

Mine were taken in Livingston Co. Bow and Gun buck.

 

[Arrow Flinger]

Heres my best NY bucks. The one on the right scores 161" net. All of these bucks were taken on public land!

Heres a better pic of my biggest one.

[nybuckboy]

The buck on the left is my best NY buck, killed with a shotgun in 1999 with a gross score of 131, 9pt. The buck in the middle is my bow kill from Illinois in 2009 gross score 150, 8pt. The one on the right is a rifle kill with a gross score of 151, 11pt killed in Mexico, about 2 hours south of El Paso, TX.

Edited September 8, 2013 by nybuckboy

[jesse.james]

I have no pics and cant even find the horns.  Put it this way...thought it was a doe.   Story.  Well Ive been hunting this property since early bow.  The last day of bow I see a monster cross the field but stayed out 100 yards from me.  first week of rifle I see this smaller size deer slinking through the middle of the field. Head down. The rack blended in with the foliage.  Pulled up my 308 and blam...the deer disappears out of site.  Waited 20 mins and then I get down...cant pinpoint where i shot it and spend 25 mins stumbing around waist high dead grass.  Finally I see it and as I walk up I swear!.  young young 7 pointer.  Im thinking offspring to the monster I saw.  Couldnt have been much more than a 1.5yr old.  Had I given it 2-3 more years P&Y or BC.  I was elated at having my biggest buck and POed because had I saw the horns Id have let it walk.

[ATbuckhunter]

Shot this December 5th 2009 at 11:49 in beginnings of a bad snow storm. He was chasing a group of 7 does and around 250 yards away. 

[josephmrtn]

I cant wait till i kill a buck of the caliber some of you guys have!!!

[MrGroundhog]

There are some great deer in here... This is my biggest buck harvested so far, shot last Thanksgiving . Not exactly sure how old he was or how much he weighed.

[growalot]

LOL unless my eyes are really off tonight...I'd say he weighed A LOT...Great deer everyone...

[PREDATE]

2011 shotgun on public land. Still hunting in the rain. Did the Euro mount myself.

 

Edited September 9, 2013 by PREDATE

[dszymo]

chautuaqua county October 2011